
喺呢集開始之前79Please respect copyright.PENANA21FxCjRCOi
又係講啲唔等使嘅嘢先介紹番79Please respect copyright.PENANArYDfhsPD5V
呢幅係德國畫家維爾納畫嘅《德意志帝國宣告成立》79Please respect copyright.PENANAPRZv89fH9L
描繪喺1871年1月18號法國凡爾賽宮最奢華嘅鏡廳79Please respect copyright.PENANA5xnGBsBxqh
所舉行嘅德意志帝國開國大典79Please respect copyright.PENANArdRi8SZ6k8
正常嚟講呢幅畫嘅主角79Please respect copyright.PENANAQzHftNXHgp
應該係企喺台上接受一眾德意志邦國親王歡呼嘅威廉一世先啱㗎79Please respect copyright.PENANARJqbc1oVS1
不過維爾納喺呢度做咗一個連皇帝本人都認可嘅藝術改動:79Please respect copyright.PENANA7FozV01R7u
佢將本來著住同其他人一樣藍色槍服嘅俾斯麥79Please respect copyright.PENANA7tvBzGFFDN
改成白色觀禮軍服79Please respect copyright.PENANAghBGSA0EJM
成幅畫嘅著眼點79Please respect copyright.PENANAXsuK9UsRrz
就即時落喺呢位鐵血宰相身上喇79Please respect copyright.PENANAETfa9Vv8Qb
的確喺呢套俾斯麥自編自導自演、名為《德意志統一》嘅戲碼中79Please respect copyright.PENANAOcaU9GAPFl
佢先係真正嘅主角79Please respect copyright.PENANAZawql8Byr6
而呢幕就係成套戲最後最完美嘅結局79Please respect copyright.PENANAEEfOuiKlMq
不過我諗就算係最瘋狂嘅劇作家79Please respect copyright.PENANAi25jYysTzs
都唔會將個結尾鋪排到咁超現實
嗰日係普魯士升格為王國170周年紀念日79Please respect copyright.PENANATsumrsKEqf
俾斯麥特登揀呢日79Please respect copyright.PENANALoE6DOjnsC
要南德嗰班教廷嘅走狗79Please respect copyright.PENANAgcDf3qZOFE
山長水遠嚟到法國79Please respect copyright.PENANAhe6vDYUeSe
親身向佢地眼中普魯士呢個路德宗異端俯首稱臣79Please respect copyright.PENANASDk1lqszF1
本身已經夠晒痴線79Please respect copyright.PENANAJgUncnkIyo
而更加癲嘅其實係個場地79Please respect copyright.PENANA1EXVJxevWh
要知嗰時普法戰爭仲未正式打完79Please respect copyright.PENANA6NtuA3YalQ
巴黎正被德意志聯軍圍城圍到彈盡糧絕79Please respect copyright.PENANAYaRGrbCv8P
場仗已經輸到咁樣衰喇79Please respect copyright.PENANA7f4fUhlmOc
而家仲要畀班日爾曼生蕃喺凡爾賽宮耀武揚威79Please respect copyright.PENANA2UOPvDFeja
對素來以天朝大國自居嘅法國佬嚟講79Please respect copyright.PENANA9nWM6X2Vhz
無異於傷口上㨘鹽79Please respect copyright.PENANAFJzRC0hgxO
……原來德意志嘅榮耀係奠基於法蘭西嘅恥辱上79Please respect copyright.PENANAi3bwrt7kyW
俾斯麥呢齣《德意志統一》以呢場對法國最華麗嘅羞辱作結79Please respect copyright.PENANAjUgPsQQeGy
的確相當詩情畫意79Please respect copyright.PENANAyo9kuBFjtp
之但係歷史唔係一齣戲79Please respect copyright.PENANAvc85gb4Fx1
唔係話拍完個結尾就可以收工去拎飯盒79Please respect copyright.PENANAEmrf9JBhmD
歷史係由一連串嘅選擇所組成79Please respect copyright.PENANA6ITiR8ZDbT
究竟當世嘅因會為後世結出咩嘅果呢?79Please respect copyright.PENANAWM68QBWyej
當事人係唔會預料到嘅79Please respect copyright.PENANAmUROoadGeI
喺命運巨輪前79Please respect copyright.PENANAuCqhwFdqTE
所有人都只可以企定定睇住佢碌過嚟79Please respect copyright.PENANANOaq1ipuz3
即使嗰個係俾斯麥79Please respect copyright.PENANAbZZzyYskm6
而家就睇睇一個佢自己都十五十六但又唔做唔得嘅決定79Please respect copyright.PENANA7Ktflnx1Gw
係點樣影響後世過億人嘅命運
望住鏡廳天花板上面一幅幅對路易十四歌功頌德嘅壁畫79Please respect copyright.PENANAUDOdqGtyJd
相信嗰時會場都會傳嚟一陣陣德國佬嘅訕笑⋯⋯79Please respect copyright.PENANAC0uFiqc5cs
…太陽皇喎征服萊茵河喎哈哈哈哈⋯⋯79Please respect copyright.PENANAcNSXgHanZf
不過俾斯麥當時應該都幾五味紛陳79Please respect copyright.PENANA0TZSRzweLj
當初用民族主義挑釁拿破崙三世發動戰爭79Please respect copyright.PENANAVtV7vmplAG
再用普魯士人嘅鐵同血喺色當生擒呢個傻仔79Please respect copyright.PENANAJplHPOxvoZ
佢即時變身成為德意志民族嘅救世主79Please respect copyright.PENANAS320Qd4gWB
成個德國都畀佢搞到集體高潮79Please respect copyright.PENANAxwydQX7EF7
咁先可以極速令各德意志邦國79Please respect copyright.PENANA8i46aoJjW7
尤其係以巴伐利亞為首嘅南德諸國79Please respect copyright.PENANAZxL1IN5iC9
放低歷史文化語言宗教等等等等嘅分歧79Please respect copyright.PENANARRKW23VlVB
接受普魯士主導下嘅統一79Please respect copyright.PENANA1HPuMGBKOt
剩係呢點都足以令佢成為歷史偉人喇
色當會戰後兩個阿叔喺公園長櫈吹水
拿破崙三世親手向威廉一世交出配劍
喺勃蘭登堡門掛起嘅橫額79Please respect copyright.PENANA4uJORPuCcD
上面寫住「色當──由上帝引領嘅轉捩點」
德意志人集體高潮示意圖
要知道民族主義係一把雙刃劍79Please respect copyright.PENANA6Ktcp9RPPW
用得佢就要預咗要畀佢反劈79Please respect copyright.PENANA05DLzC7ERG
當初俾斯麥引法國開拖79Please respect copyright.PENANAchvRl2hrVD
其實只係想為德意志樹立一個共同嘅敵人79Please respect copyright.PENANAnqp6QroCsz
去催化統一啫79Please respect copyright.PENANAHop6fBXQba
不過普法戰爭似乎進展得太順利喇79Please respect copyright.PENANApH3GHhw7Ic
逐漸成個德意志開始有一種共識79Please respect copyright.PENANA9jf0hTazcH
要喺呢場戰爭中攞到更多79Please respect copyright.PENANAzolHBaa1w1
其中一個訴求就係阿爾薩斯-洛林
呢兩笪位於萊茵河上游西岸、主要係日爾曼人聚居嘅地方79Please respect copyright.PENANAc962MAqqjh
自古以來就係德國不可分割嘅一部分79Please respect copyright.PENANAa63rzRUDoz
係神聖不可侵犯嘅(好似係)79Please respect copyright.PENANAVli117Rdpa
不過喺17世紀79Please respect copyright.PENANAHOkWf2aGVd
畀路易十四以一連串嘅戰爭吞併後79Please respect copyright.PENANAoSMF7kV0ra
呢度嘅日爾曼人就被迫寄人籬下喇(又係好似係)79Please respect copyright.PENANAoPYWzitqqD
睇住啲同胞日日處於水深火熱之中79Please respect copyright.PENANAxrUxyVzqKp
任何有血性嘅德國人都唔會無動於衷79Please respect copyright.PENANA5SjurOvCq8
咁而家場仗都贏到開晒巷喇79Please respect copyright.PENANAkMYBYeMlO2
唔趁機收番嗰度都唔係人啦係咪
日爾曼尼亞請求俾斯麥拯救萊茵河對岸被拿破崙三世挾持嘅羔羊阿爾薩斯-洛林
威廉一世同時任總參謀長老毛奇相當支持79Please respect copyright.PENANAnHBG4yj8FZ
一來嗰度位處法國同德國之間79Please respect copyright.PENANAj3kl4kcbHp
歷來都係兩國必爭之地79Please respect copyright.PENANAX6FRG9HIFd
而喺“法佔”嗰兩百幾年期間79Please respect copyright.PENANAUhyE8wO848
兩大省會史特拉斯堡同梅斯都被法國建設成要塞化城市79Please respect copyright.PENANAeVX3gQODrA
喺第日同法國再開拖時79Please respect copyright.PENANAR6QxKYxAOM
呢度就會係萊茵河西岸最堅實嘅橋頭堡79Please respect copyright.PENANAkrJ5YfVE5l
另外洛林嘅孚日山脈係出名嘅大礦區79Please respect copyright.PENANAW64aU0Fh0W
盛產鐵礦石同煤炭79Please respect copyright.PENANAcKwpgxQpJC
又因為位處萊茵河畔漕運便捷79Please respect copyright.PENANA7FiEAm4Yev
有原料有能源運輸成本又低79Please respect copyright.PENANAwxtQis1NMG
工業革命後呢度嘅鋼鐵廠就如雨後春筍79Please respect copyright.PENANArvsYfoAj6K
呢啲永不竭熄嘅高爐79Please respect copyright.PENANApMxdqcZdGr
將會令德國嘅鋼材成本顯著下降79Please respect copyright.PENANAG2P7LIZ2Ct
無論軍工產業抑或民用商品都會得益79Please respect copyright.PENANAPynvO5hr9r
再加上路易十四以來歷任法王對呢度相當厚愛79Please respect copyright.PENANAoYNaGUCBcc
用以迫害雨格諾宗新教徒嘅楓丹白露敕令79Please respect copyright.PENANA5ghB8ral6v
同全國性嘅標準法語運動79Please respect copyright.PENANAvfPFxH1Zy7
都冇喺呢度實施79Please respect copyright.PENANAX3yb5O78oD
自由嘅宗教同語言政策79Please respect copyright.PENANA62GkJvDauQ
吸引周邊嘅資金同人才遷入79Please respect copyright.PENANAyy0UeUqLzc
商業活動相當蓬勃79Please respect copyright.PENANATi3LdiMVAE
凡此種種都造就呢度成為軍事同商貿要地79Please respect copyright.PENANAjt9jxb5f9m之但係呢啲都唔係重點79Please respect copyright.PENANAVXgSzG3ZIh
對威廉一世呢位老國王嚟講79Please respect copyright.PENANASqwl9mAs7p
一統德意志就係佢畢生志業79Please respect copyright.PENANAPn4K8Y1FQ5
嗰時整個德意志都期待79Please respect copyright.PENANAHSk6jdE92P
普魯士可以趁機收番阿爾薩斯-洛林做戰利品79Please respect copyright.PENANAReap6dcUyt
如果佢唔攞79Please respect copyright.PENANAZiCBAkwn6W
以巴伐利亞為首嘅南德諸國79Please respect copyright.PENANAnmlqv5rRnF
就唔可能咁順攤79Please respect copyright.PENANAUI5Ckxnn4L
臣服於佢呢位「北德意志邦聯」主席喇79Please respect copyright.PENANAAaLEF5Nw7m
整個德意志統一將會功虧一簣79Please respect copyright.PENANANyFvn0OMrY
或者最起碼唔會喺短期內實現79Please respect copyright.PENANAG21NMp7XRj
嗰時佢都73歲喇79Please respect copyright.PENANAAtTEuPSGW9
仲有幾多時間等?
普法戰爭時期威廉一世畫像
呢啲嘢俾斯麥當然明白79Please respect copyright.PENANAmqB7VrdiLO
望住阿爾薩斯-洛林佢自己都流晒口水79Please respect copyright.PENANAwQqUkQq68Q
不過佢有第二個諗法79Please respect copyright.PENANALJZaIAOg4Y
據佢後嚟本回憶錄所講79Please respect copyright.PENANAUKuwDIXm4T
喺拿破崙三世被擒後79Please respect copyright.PENANApF2xZiJ73G
威廉一世、老毛奇同佢79Please respect copyright.PENANA6WAvZgTpqf
曾經有過一場激烈嘅討論79Please respect copyright.PENANAhBGzT0iMJQ
去決定一個咩型式嘅勝利79Please respect copyright.PENANA6fsrGwMuSY
俾斯麥所預算最理想嘅情況79Please respect copyright.PENANAhwg9atLCal
其實係好似普奧戰爭咁點到即止;79Please respect copyright.PENANAyDIEsUSdLj
令哈布斯堡意識到兩國實力嘅差距之餘79Please respect copyright.PENANAxaKqrTQq6B
又冇令奧地利人感到難堪79Please respect copyright.PENANAVKQHrjSfRl
激起佢地嘅民族情緒79Please respect copyright.PENANADfwI78JjCt
咁奧地利先冇畀民意迫上絕路反枱79Please respect copyright.PENANANTwRAvTEpb
兩國之後嘅關係先可以回復正常79Please respect copyright.PENANAZ2wmpfa1uC
當初佢就係以呢點勸服威廉一世79Please respect copyright.PENANAUUsNjCXVAf
唔好對哈布斯堡獅子開大口79Please respect copyright.PENANABS4qtcuB45
攞奧地利本土任何領土79Please respect copyright.PENANAj6BAE1hF0K
尤其係波希米亞79Please respect copyright.PENANA8B01wpRheZ
淨係叫佢讓番個德意志統一個主導權就算喇
位於波希米亞嘅尼科爾斯堡79Please respect copyright.PENANAmXfv7h5EFU
普奥戰爭時普魯士佔領區嘅臨時總部79Please respect copyright.PENANAtXZ2tinIfu
嗰時威廉一世對波希米亞都係流晒口水79Please respect copyright.PENANAkCUOQvPrNJ
為此仲同俾斯麥拗到面紅耳赤79Please respect copyright.PENANASxHAhn0Ylu
俾斯麥直情要用辭職+當住佢面由呢度4樓跳落去嚟要脅79Please respect copyright.PENANAJYHjlFuEn0
先勸得掂佢腦細79Please respect copyright.PENANA6rWPkOdhgY
事實亦都證明佢呢個決定係正確79Please respect copyright.PENANAi71DEAWHua
自此奧地利就畀普魯士79Please respect copyright.PENANAEUNwXKmUDg
由德意志大哥打到變男朋友79Please respect copyright.PENANAGqy2iIXQao
從此貼貼服服咁做跟班
當然俾斯麥又唔會天真到以為第日同法國就會相親相愛啦79Please respect copyright.PENANAWJPs5TXWhU
正如色當會戰後佢同法軍司令溫普芬將軍談判時都講:79Please respect copyright.PENANALZRmI781MG
「呢200年嚟79Please respect copyright.PENANAlx9kn264nC
你地班撚樣對我地已經宣咗卅次戰喇79Please respect copyright.PENANAVektzZDQYK
我肯定你地以後都會繼續」79Please respect copyright.PENANAnhKR73QgIP
佢深知法國絶唔會容忍一個統一而又強大嘅德國喺佢隔離79Please respect copyright.PENANA0tcjou30qc
佢地第日必定會借故挑起事端試圖削弱德國79Please respect copyright.PENANADyp7eNtqIn
不過如果今次和談個條件唔係咁嚴苛嘅話79Please respect copyright.PENANACltuB0gmL0
只要將隻鑊推去拿破崙三世嘅傻仔外交上79Please respect copyright.PENANAWSl1mUAzMI
法國民間嘅反響就唔會太大79Please respect copyright.PENANAZTFtq4TUN6
到時法國一時三刻都未必搵到藉口去發爛渣79Please respect copyright.PENANAdaNBi0TRsU
而將來嘅紛爭亦冇咁易上升到戰爭層面79Please respect copyright.PENANA80N5eMV5Sm
咁德意志民族先有足夠時間同餘力去發展79Please respect copyright.PENANA2JJI6DoJTe
縱使讓步會令統一進程減慢79Please respect copyright.PENANAelrWdov5Fv
但對德意志嘅未來似乎更有裨益
作為當時歐陸人口最多最工業化嘅國家79Please respect copyright.PENANAOtOkb64ApT
法國同奧地利嘅情況相當唔同79Please respect copyright.PENANANwpk5KYqVb
今次輸得咁柒79Please respect copyright.PENANAbpC0lcGiMK
完全係因為拿破崙三世呢個傻仔送頭79Please respect copyright.PENANAKtPM5THNNg
同法軍參謀部指揮失誤啫79Please respect copyright.PENANAPkzmRyYGWR
對法國整體國力嚟講79Please respect copyright.PENANAPnyQkJHi9I
並冇傷筋錯骨嘅影響79Please respect copyright.PENANAoWGGAZ3lbs
即使嗰時整個法國北部都畀德軍控制79Please respect copyright.PENANARkdJnNpFuM
南部好似聖伊天、蒂勒同沙泰勒羅嗰幾個兵工廠仍然繼續運作79Please respect copyright.PENANAWhgq1r8cFN
源源不絕咁生產彈藥同大炮79Please respect copyright.PENANAvpHlOp7nbF
而啱啱推翻咗拿破崙三世嘅國民防衛政府79Please respect copyright.PENANA1X1h6ZQF2l
仍然可以臨時拉伕50萬人衝去同德軍死過79Please respect copyright.PENANAvDAGKKSKY7
只不過因為巴黎被圍軍令不順79Please respect copyright.PENANAMhH3OYsueh
所以先組織唔到有效嘅反擊
法國嘅軍備其實並唔比普魯士差79Please respect copyright.PENANAcsIBIXkVlH
好似呢支Mitrailleuse79Please respect copyright.PENANAKMSxGGsZER
就係世上第一種應用喺戰場嘅機關槍79Please respect copyright.PENANAfZZ1A9zUtf
作為法軍嘅秘密武器79Please respect copyright.PENANABJLQBJa46Z
佢秘密到一個程度79Please respect copyright.PENANAaAxxKAalCS
係只有少數士兵識用79Please respect copyright.PENANA3aBZY4lT29
所以當嗰啲士兵死晒後79Please respect copyright.PENANAiFg4Cmb84d
呢啲槍就擺晒喺度喇79Please respect copyright.PENANAQnRnTZoeAv
呢個係法軍輸到貼地嘅其中一個原因
法國嘅底蘊的確係深不可測79Please respect copyright.PENANAcsPB7B1AAZ
單憑德國自己係冇可能全面征服法國79Please respect copyright.PENANAssWExqTRVD
況且基於勢力平衡79Please respect copyright.PENANA8SFmJkqTY7
其他列強亦絕唔會袖手旁觀79Please respect copyright.PENANAujmdAankvR
本來俾斯麥預想中嘅劇本79Please respect copyright.PENANA5vdDtuOVlu
係以優秀嘅鐵路網絡79Please respect copyright.PENANArwpqCJ5oMF
快速動員大批軍隊79Please respect copyright.PENANA18b9iVzsQR
對法國狠狠重擊79Please respect copyright.PENANA5sufxZBX9a
再用寬厚嘅條件議和79Please respect copyright.PENANA6GiWM22LM6
但吞併阿爾薩斯-洛林就會令呢個劇本落空79Please respect copyright.PENANAw52sAThOFV
要知道對法國嚟講79Please respect copyright.PENANAsxBJjyxwV9
嗰度就係命門所在79Please respect copyright.PENANAemVTKDVPSb
重鎮梅斯距離巴黎只有300公里79Please respect copyright.PENANAxHJiIProS6
中間仲要係平原無險可守79Please respect copyright.PENANANpL7vo37Pq
割咗嗰度就等如打開個門口任德國佬自出自入79Please respect copyright.PENANA6Y6yuPBFPG
無論之後係保皇黨抑或係共和派上台79Please respect copyright.PENANAwJxzstHxjl
都絶冇可能忍受得了79Please respect copyright.PENANARhcMAqW3Wg
一日唔攞番79Please respect copyright.PENANAye0t3nClEA
佢地之間都唔會有和平79Please respect copyright.PENANAVspEM60Vqf
成個劇情就會去咗法國復仇之路嗰度 79Please respect copyright.PENANAq1DzC5ea3N
而對即將統一嘅德意志嚟講79Please respect copyright.PENANALgVCe74MO9
和平發展先係最緊要79Please respect copyright.PENANAus4nhkKFiR
如果今次咁大咬嘅話79Please respect copyright.PENANA426D6MHsu0
德法關係惡化將會不可逆轉79Please respect copyright.PENANAVdyeamXBJL
到時就要虛耗寶貴嘅國家資源79Please respect copyright.PENANAV1fJA6faao
去防範一個強大而又敵對嘅法國79Please respect copyright.PENANAFDiAdh0eqv
而將來真係起衝突時79Please respect copyright.PENANAOXaaJicPRh
其他列強會點樣歸邊亦係未知之數79Please respect copyright.PENANAOk6GTJDECg
俾斯麥深知縱使有諸多好處79Please respect copyright.PENANARj0XsyFllV
但係對整個德意志民族嚟講79Please respect copyright.PENANA6PG9c81efU
阿爾薩斯-洛林其實就係糖衣毒藥喇79Please respect copyright.PENANArW8E6lPvzx
吞咗嘅話就睇吓幾時毒發79Please respect copyright.PENANAjeE14iohd2
而家俾斯麥面前係個兩難79Please respect copyright.PENANA2Q1ZjYr6Oa
一邊係國王所渴求嘅統一79Please respect copyright.PENANADtUwOd9b7F
另一邊就係德意志嘅未來79Please respect copyright.PENANA0HdtxQKZep
究竟要忠於老國王79Please respect copyright.PENANAoTxNmZGMQc
抑或忠於德意志呢?79Please respect copyright.PENANAOvkgxtaVCZ
畀著係你會點揀?
常言道歷史冇如果79Please respect copyright.PENANAJitqZvhPeu
讀史最棹忌就係開上帝之眼以今鑑古79Please respect copyright.PENANAY0TDWcRNvE
所以我唔應該喺呢度講太多嘅79Please respect copyright.PENANAFm4ZnRyyJz
不過呢亭咁嘅FF的確係幾令人神往嘅79Please respect copyright.PENANAAC4G4kofeC
而家就容許我呢個讀屎片嘅講故佬發吓噏瘋79Please respect copyright.PENANA1QJsJ6Mnyw
講講嗰個平行宇宙入面俾斯麥所預想嘅劇本:
79Please respect copyright.PENANAKNnw1B2vTt
「德國冇吞拼阿爾薩斯-洛林」
歷史證明佢嘅顧慮係正確嘅79Please respect copyright.PENANAvwrtMuLp0r
對法國佬嚟講79Please respect copyright.PENANAtK6O0dp3NN
被迫割地求和呢啖氣的確難以下嚥79Please respect copyright.PENANAM4ShTgsIZ4
自此佢地就無時無刻都想生劏德國佬報仇79Please respect copyright.PENANA8ccFJlGpog
假如法德之間冇咗阿爾薩斯-洛林呢個死結嘅話79Please respect copyright.PENANA3hxXiIIKRI
往後佢地嘅關係未必會搞到咁殭79Please respect copyright.PENANAioafRsdLNM
至於一戰會唔會因此消失呢?79Please respect copyright.PENANAf1alkbKPi8
我睇就唔一定79Please respect copyright.PENANAQJc3BKROzQ
始終奥匈同俄佬仍然會喺巴爾幹問題上糾纏79Please respect copyright.PENANAaxPkf5X0px
法國佬仍然會黐埋去俄佬度以削弱德國79Please respect copyright.PENANAqy6iuhuVvy
威廉二世仍然會玩強國崛起Weltpolitik79Please respect copyright.PENANAIbpuDjHp2P
英國仍然會掉個1蚊入嚟跟機以保海洋霸權79Please respect copyright.PENANAbAOda6x8aK
之但係冇阿爾薩斯-洛林嘅德國未必會咁強大79Please respect copyright.PENANAxJjCdDLPin
較弱勢嘅威廉二世未必會玩到咁癲79Please respect copyright.PENANA4X0Pd829tW
而仇恨值冇拉滿嘅法國79Please respect copyright.PENANAJwwbOVMhRl
又未必會喺凡爾塞條約上去到咁盡79Please respect copyright.PENANAaGubc82pwQ
某個鬍鬚仔未必會上到位79Please respect copyright.PENANAXhDGaNwZTg
大戰第二集(歐版)就未必會推出喇79Please respect copyright.PENANAxHyBPSABBU
(日版就可能會出續集嘅)79Please respect copyright.PENANAoyuntxoDwu
世界嘅格局將會完全改寫79Please respect copyright.PENANAyZvbOebHWN
(吖唔知到時喺非洲1分鐘係咪都仲係得嗰60秒79Please respect copyright.PENANAA5wqSnMQb6
而我呢篇脫更脫到痴撚咗線嘅故仔又會點寫呢?)
呢幅係畫家貝坦尼爾喺1887年所畫嘅“The black stain”79Please respect copyright.PENANAUzIhGVxPqe
描繪一班上緊地理課嘅法國學生
再諗深一層79Please respect copyright.PENANAkHpFYA6VRI
喺呢幅畫入面受緊愛國教育嘅細路79Please respect copyright.PENANAOUPBktNJGF
好大機會廿幾年後死喺凡爾登絞肉機度79Please respect copyright.PENANAaLT0rtLAcG
而幸存者嘅後代又好大機會變納粹亡魂79Please respect copyright.PENANApqVVTMR6ld
古語有云:「以史為鏡」79Please respect copyright.PENANAgG2cct9GyI
而家咁嘅形勢下79Please respect copyright.PENANAUZAEtmQHmt
「我們是最後一代,謝謝」的確可能係最理性嘅選擇
當然現實就唔會有個水晶球畀佢撚住嚟做決定啦79Please respect copyright.PENANAD44g7SzXqf
吞併阿爾薩斯-洛林79Please respect copyright.PENANAz1Lx8zYjCd
喺嗰個時空的確唔可以話係錯嘅79Please respect copyright.PENANAy3VNi9RZKa
成個問題嘅關鍵79Please respect copyright.PENANAq55JrcOwGd
其實係普魯士決策層(包括佢自己)都認為79Please respect copyright.PENANAVRY5C0Mpjf
德法之間必須有個緩衝區79Please respect copyright.PENANAOzVKs0YWI8
以防止法國第日覆桌79Please respect copyright.PENANAgkEaMK8veo
德國冇英倫海峽呢啲咁完美嘅地理阻隔79Please respect copyright.PENANAQzt7Wst8XT
自然就唔會有好似當年維也納會議一樣79Please respect copyright.PENANA8jQgKAn2rp
對法國一笑抿恩仇呢啲咁奢侈嘅選項啦79Please respect copyright.PENANAU0joNn5Ngd
而作為最後嘗試79Please respect copyright.PENANAzTZUveMNt1
俾斯麥曾經提議將嗰度交畀中立國瑞士托管79Please respect copyright.PENANA7aFHyKN7rQ
以避免直接吞併79Please respect copyright.PENANAEIyY4OQuc0
不過瑞士佬精甩尾79Please respect copyright.PENANAjNknFUy2RI
話你都霎戇嘅搵我嚟做磨心79Please respect copyright.PENANACbSwm1T8U1
有咩你地兩個自己拆掂佢啦!?79Please respect copyright.PENANAGa9OzQbtIG
連最後嘅希望都冇埋79Please respect copyright.PENANAzhcO0VuG40
咁既然都行唔到最理想劇本咯79Please respect copyright.PENANAJV9uEzJMAI
一不做二不休79Please respect copyright.PENANA2YwU2gaxM1
掉番轉頭去盡啲啦不如79Please respect copyright.PENANAQq4AULkQdz
企硬要法國割讓阿爾薩斯-洛林79Please respect copyright.PENANAiJU9QMP4zE
開個佢地無法承受嘅戰敗賠款79Please respect copyright.PENANAl6Q6QPmNGk
再盡情羞辱佢地以團結德意志79Please respect copyright.PENANA6zRi5kDdDo
咁先有本文開頭嗰一幕大龍鳳79Please respect copyright.PENANAEA3WVMY1uW
嗰刻嘅鏡廳達官貴人觥籌交錯79Please respect copyright.PENANABYWaprRb9J
不過當時只有俾斯麥先意識到79Please respect copyright.PENANAQAoyod5pJZ
阿爾薩斯-洛林79Please respect copyright.PENANArrT69B47QW
就係德意志統一所要背負嘅原罪喇⋯⋯
無可否認法國佬真係幾小器79Please respect copyright.PENANAwzorhhbt8Z
一戰後特登揀番喺鏡廳簽《凡爾賽條約》79Please respect copyright.PENANAK4Ac3I9ibV
不過話時話79Please respect copyright.PENANAIlkH4dxTfx
一個場地79Please respect copyright.PENANA0DwQKJf1XB
能夠同時見證到一個帝國嘅開端同覆滅79Please respect copyright.PENANA22MtCxwBsC
歷史上都相當少見...79Please respect copyright.PENANAUA2KpISsoj
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.79Please respect copyright.PENANAVnDoCYqQQm
79Please respect copyright.PENANA1dPRHNqtuS
唔知呢度門有冇機會成為其中一份子呢?
79Please respect copyright.PENANALQcVTU4CQW
79Please respect copyright.PENANAXPsiGftAPb
79Please respect copyright.PENANAqgJGoItqyI
79Please respect copyright.PENANAf5XkFGUi9X
79Please respect copyright.PENANAhcseoyvUPz
...待續
ns3.22.27.22da2