【賀!】
本文點閱率成功擠進當週排行第三名5888Please respect copyright.PENANAy0AHT5qH3k
可見大家都很關心這事5888Please respect copyright.PENANAla8iNcgTUX
大家如果有更多關於角角的黑料5888Please respect copyright.PENANAmZivshwq0o
也都歡迎提供給我作為參考5888Please respect copyright.PENANA6KIFa9VvN1
5888Please respect copyright.PENANASZbT121A8C
這段期間也感謝不少作家朋友5888Please respect copyright.PENANAS88X1oUNhl
對我被謾罵一事提出關心5888Please respect copyright.PENANA9D1In0FzMn
5888Please respect copyright.PENANArOQvyVoA77
但沒辦法,網路生態就是這樣5888Please respect copyright.PENANAfhFNTfcvGj
開FB本帳時都是好好先生/小姐5888Please respect copyright.PENANAq0nMS6JAxq
私底下卻是個噁心的雙面人5888Please respect copyright.PENANAfEQAudy0CM
利用匿名機制不會被告就口無遮攔5888Please respect copyright.PENANAZoei9i2B03
敵暗我明就是這樣了(攤手5888Please respect copyright.PENANA53BtGcIuDq
我能做的也只有盡可能勤勞更新放出聲明囉~5888Please respect copyright.PENANAVxsjgsZkd8
5888Please respect copyright.PENANAuB81nP3N1R
【回應抹黑聲明】
噗浪有腳穿腦粉對我貼標籤5888Please respect copyright.PENANAtvszm0Of6n
把我說成是落選崩潰仔&巨嬰5888Please respect copyright.PENANANIZu2OYoy4
5888Please respect copyright.PENANAVqL0MiYAnL
我底下有說可以問候我母親5888Please respect copyright.PENANAOwTRK89oEK
所以對這些批判老早就有心理準備5888Please respect copyright.PENANA9CREVRZNZU什麼落選崩潰仔、直男、巨嬰的標籤都來了💗5888Please respect copyright.PENANAy835GCNRgv畢竟比起看完我的作品,直接貼標籤快多了對吧😏5888Please respect copyright.PENANARopSk69XV7
之後要是被角角提告我也不意外了5888Please respect copyright.PENANAmNdnHXJYRh
我會開戰就是已經做好覺悟5888Please respect copyright.PENANAIqbkY3tzeD
所以每一段都會以不影響觀看體驗為前提5888Please respect copyright.PENANAZJEiu2bl3C
竭盡所能附上證據5888Please respect copyright.PENANAoLZjQ4y3fr
5888Please respect copyright.PENANAM5qA4SD2yk
但為了新讀者著想5888Please respect copyright.PENANAaVxarAnBna
該澄清的東西還是應該講清楚5888Please respect copyright.PENANAPsj8uBixYa
5888Please respect copyright.PENANAlwwjwyqvoW
首先,我這篇文早在4個月前5888Please respect copyright.PENANAuslL6zqJST
也就是 7/3 就已經寫完前 11 項5888Please respect copyright.PENANA6LOqDnx1R0
何來落選崩潰之說?5888Please respect copyright.PENANACJRf3zHhaL
啊你們要說我7月就已經預知自己會落選……5888Please respect copyright.PENANA3sNrdhN4Fb
嘿!那我還真的無Fuck說(掩面笑5888Please respect copyright.PENANAYiEsnvwzCc
5888Please respect copyright.PENANAmsV1VzUFJW
各位可以點開留言區看看5888Please respect copyright.PENANAgtm7zjYFwF
四個月前就有人認同這篇文章進行打賞了5888Please respect copyright.PENANAQYya8PCZgR
何來偏頗之說?5888Please respect copyright.PENANAx9CFwZTjt2
反倒偷偷說那邊的發言永遠是那3~5個人才偏頗吧😏5888Please respect copyright.PENANAc8u6o7xxCo
5888Please respect copyright.PENANAQys8VLNm64
而且這篇文章明顯有地方和現狀不符5888Please respect copyright.PENANAlBDjdR81sb
例如第5點角角就說他們已開始研擬改善5888Please respect copyright.PENANAseFLuNGaNR
這不正是我迫使角川不得不做出應對的證據嗎欸嘿!原來角角官方有認真看這篇文欸~5888Please respect copyright.PENANA0ePzKPDOeg
我好興奮啊.gif
別再說我是巨嬰吵著要糖吃啦~5888Please respect copyright.PENANAPy1AC9tGI9
真以為角角發的糖我敢吃嗎?5888Please respect copyright.PENANASgLxUgCEu8
那是裹著糖衣的毒藥啊!5888Please respect copyright.PENANAChNOV9BEDH
5888Please respect copyright.PENANARIby8jhBeL
【更新歷程】
7/9 還債活動結束5888Please respect copyright.PENANACjvDycGVlG
10/31 複選名單公布後新增兩事件(第12、13點)5888Please respect copyright.PENANAhbsZyp2M1S
11/2 觀看部分入選作品後新增兩事件(第14、15點)5888Please respect copyright.PENANA7J7hj3IZgA
11/2 角角針對初選回應後,新增我個人的回應(第16點)5888Please respect copyright.PENANA1KxWGU4fMT
11/3 針對噗浪偷偷說不實抹黑新增回應(開頭聲明)5888Please respect copyright.PENANAomlRICesCc
5888Please respect copyright.PENANAf3ffEvn9qP
1、為什麼標題看起來有點酸?
因為這篇就是要來吐槽角角者的5888Please respect copyright.PENANAzfdgKVQMO7
如果無法忍受角角被我大肆批判5888Please respect copyright.PENANA3tP6odvbxz
請在留言區問候我母親後高歌離席5888Please respect copyright.PENANAGJ6TKSzSgb
5888Please respect copyright.PENANAtHquSZPDC2
2、角角者是啥?
那個出版過無數作品5888Please respect copyright.PENANAtLt2ADFxwv
成功引領許多輕小說動畫化的角川5888Please respect copyright.PENANAkePxQETI23
其台灣代理商終於成立了中文小說平台!5888Please respect copyright.PENANAfHsK0VCK6U
5888Please respect copyright.PENANANTpZy76lTz
消息大概是從2021年底開始宣傳5888Please respect copyright.PENANAzm7pWHsVaB
當時網路上就能看到相關消息5888Please respect copyright.PENANAvcWpB1kLOl
還贈送50點閱讀金吸引讀者加入5888Please respect copyright.PENANAzntXvzFAEp有夠少、使用期限還不到兩個月,廢到笑
好啦,這是題外話5888Please respect copyright.PENANAnwPnwsjiqD
5888Please respect copyright.PENANAdfK81jGM9s
歷經【貓橘事件】後5888Please respect copyright.PENANAonEg7KiaLz
(不清楚該事件可點連結補完)5888Please respect copyright.PENANAuLl64RNwNB
角川終於再度有意扶植台灣創作者5888Please respect copyright.PENANAaWkZ6oBdsH
舉辦《百萬小說創作大賞》
然後就出現了一堆迷之操作5888Please respect copyright.PENANAQqXDBBoU2n5888Please respect copyright.PENANAHYIz11BIGv
讓人驚歎號與問號不斷5888Please respect copyright.PENANA7r56LdiEjJ
堪稱【角角的奇妙比賽】
5888Please respect copyright.PENANAESiPNA7jSV
3、奇怪的合作對象
這次比賽角角者找了LINE TV做為合作對象5888Please respect copyright.PENANApTV9ezPI05
號稱是「跨界合作」5888Please respect copyright.PENANA3jRp9PtCQS
一般人看到可能覺得沒什麼大問題5888Please respect copyright.PENANATDUetkXWid
但我自己是看得滿頭問號
LINE TV用戶明顯是以「連續劇」為主要觀看目標5888Please respect copyright.PENANASNofazCHUz
台灣角川則專門代理日系輕小說5888Please respect copyright.PENANA1zFloQEnh4
這兩個題材的客群根本八竿子打不著啊?5888Please respect copyright.PENANAYzN31QEuWM
多數參賽者投角川為的是「動畫化」5888Please respect copyright.PENANAJJ5D8d2VhY
而非「影視化」吧?5888Please respect copyright.PENANA8y5E1mI3iE
5888Please respect copyright.PENANAUYMgEnKU5C難道我母親魷魚遊戲看一看5888Please respect copyright.PENANA2oJjypKN4S5888Please respect copyright.PENANA6aDqsu4w91
會突然想看刀劍神域真人版嗎?
(想影視化不如投已有不少成功案例的鏡文學)5888Please respect copyright.PENANA70R5JruVia
5888Please respect copyright.PENANAFaNenIFLhS
把動畫做成真人版有哪幾部能看的?5888Please respect copyright.PENANAZUQGaqgSSg
還是說角角有信心把異世界題材給影視化?5888Please respect copyright.PENANAfluSwHYJ0s
5888Please respect copyright.PENANABsL84Rhvuj
異世界、未來科技、太空大戰等幻想類作品5888Please respect copyright.PENANAMOLGt0XOtr
那絕不是他們喜歡的東西5888Please respect copyright.PENANAR16qTNUqQy
也是可以投投看啦,畢竟我也不知道他們在想啥
直播中舉了這四個IP當例子……5888Please respect copyright.PENANA48flugqFV6
這裡面哪個原作是小說?5888Please respect copyright.PENANA8LXpTZ55Mi
你是《百萬小說創作大賞》5888Please respect copyright.PENANA9kvkmMNiee
拿這些當範例不覺得尷尬跑題嗎?5888Please respect copyright.PENANAENV7dy2bop
再說,目前台灣文創界5888Please respect copyright.PENANAloizzx9Uby
有能力、有資源、有心要做出這種國際大IP嗎?5888Please respect copyright.PENANAwwcjQsHFR9看你們比賽辦成這樣我是不敢想啦5888Please respect copyright.PENANAajhnd5GKuE
5888Please respect copyright.PENANAfVPHZ8iNiQ
4、爛到不行的網站設計
如果你覺得上面吐槽官方直播火力不夠5888Please respect copyright.PENANAfcy2Dc0LJ1
那恭喜你看到這裡5888Please respect copyright.PENANAbs64j7LOeB
真正的主炮要來了
下面我將透過分析來告訴各位5888Please respect copyright.PENANAKyddLB6nCz
角角網頁並不是為了創作者而建5888Please respect copyright.PENANAUUqyep6bgF
是為了辦《百萬小說創作大賞》臨時架出來的空殼5888Please respect copyright.PENANAEJLH2h9GjW
順便用比賽流量宣傳一下簽約作品5888Please respect copyright.PENANAPpPcTUSBG2
根本沒有注入小說平台該有的靈魂5888Please respect copyright.PENANA9jcn8iXy35
仔細看完我接下來講的每個點5888Please respect copyright.PENANAjNVThW97Fp
讓我竭盡全力說服你
啊如果你覺得角角就是神5888Please respect copyright.PENANAtMy8jGNF8M
我整篇都在鬼扯5888Please respect copyright.PENANAJ7Pgf1JIA7
看完後可以到留言區問候一下我母親5888Please respect copyright.PENANAKzb0RAw6B4
5888Please respect copyright.PENANAduKgUzm0Hu
5、防止機器人灌票的登入機制
不少創作者為了維持作品熱度5888Please respect copyright.PENANAkTdHma6rJG
會選擇日更或定期更新5888Please respect copyright.PENANAWNsVqDAyC7
因此,多數小說網不太會自動把人登出5888Please respect copyright.PENANA9GdcCYAfFw
就算登出,也會幫忙紀錄帳密5888Please respect copyright.PENANAt4bnb0zqPw
有興趣的自己查,我就不一一截圖了
Penana:不登出5888Please respect copyright.PENANAtJiA7RZYoi
巴哈:如果換IP會登出5888Please respect copyright.PENANA0z2p3cq1eE
POPO:會登出但可紀錄帳密5888Please respect copyright.PENANACg8aSk3cRi
鏡文學:不登出
欸嘿!這個角角神奇了!5888Please respect copyright.PENANAg0SnMMRev4
每次關掉網頁都給你自動登出5888Please respect copyright.PENANAHqz2j5hL2W
而且不紀錄帳密,每次登入都要手打
你們知道是為什麼嗎?5888Please respect copyright.PENANA8PpV2rYFDX
為了辦人氣獎比賽防機器人進來灌票R!5888Please respect copyright.PENANAJPBAYwjiPP
所以才說他們打一開始就不是「方便創作者」5888Please respect copyright.PENANA7hNjq3kvU5
而是「方便辦比賽」5888Please respect copyright.PENANA1vnhHfgTRp
5888Please respect copyright.PENANAbR0hq1CVU3
6、開站到現在(2022/7/9)完全沒有優化
這些瑕疵要嘛是官方人員自己沒在用5888Please respect copyright.PENANAEwXn4NH28p
不然就是懶得再花錢請工程師來改5888Please respect copyright.PENANAJzLLxfRG4a
5888Please respect copyright.PENANAoMVu40451n
首先是這張圖,看到底下寫著【立即投稿】嗎?
你第一直覺認為這連結會連去哪裡?5888Please respect copyright.PENANAzsi2trhBMs
正常來說應該是小說比賽官網5888Please respect copyright.PENANARMHRP59lqg
或著可以投稿文章的地方吧?
結果點下去……欸?我不是要投稿嗎?怎麼跑到LINE TV官網?
接著整個網站最令我詬病的就屬創作中心5888Please respect copyright.PENANAf1T7va0QmM
如果你之前小說寫到一半想繼續更新5888Please respect copyright.PENANAkivZxiinKL
按下「開始創作」5888Please respect copyright.PENANA2HLTZ7Rk66
他竟然是直接幫你【開一本新書】!
這時候就要問了5888Please respect copyright.PENANA5W4M9ZuZdh
「那我之前寫一半的小說想繼續更新怎麼辦?」
5888Please respect copyright.PENANAPTWQJ9aQVy
你得先點最左邊的「文章數」5888Please respect copyright.PENANARxVGV1NN4j
進去後選擇要編輯的作品5888Please respect copyright.PENANA1UOp1CuFX4
接著拉到最下面「新增文章」5888Please respect copyright.PENANAx5jO0EUQBp
欸!那萬一我有上百上千話5888Please respect copyright.PENANAmCc5ECJ5xS
不就要往下拉個老半天?5888Please respect copyright.PENANAmywh0cCSaY
哪家小說網新增鍵藏得像你們這麼深的?5888Please respect copyright.PENANAVpB2DBRTUQ
5888Please respect copyright.PENANAO5qGTC9jP3
7、將素人作家的作品直接消失
角角在最一開始有分兩個頁面5888Please respect copyright.PENANAvESJFS6y3c
首頁給簽約作品,5888Please respect copyright.PENANASWOjaZ9P2O
點個按鍵就能切到素人作家頁面
我在他們開放投稿第一天5888Please respect copyright.PENANAiYdqseZi9M
就申請認證作家PO文連載5888Please respect copyright.PENANA1OXLs5Lebr
當時素人作品欄首頁每天都有我的作品5888Please respect copyright.PENANA8gs1wDeoly
後來雖然慢慢被大佬擠下去5888Please respect copyright.PENANANna5fkOZHA
但至少也有排在前20名內
然而6月初的某天,網頁突然大改5888Please respect copyright.PENANA4v3Ihc0Pih
首頁變成只看得到簽約作品5888Please respect copyright.PENANALfU8La1MwS
素人創作全部消失5888Please respect copyright.PENANA6nAy7AFyPw
改成只能手動Key名字查5888Please respect copyright.PENANA1veFE6fEVE
(請恕我無法附圖,畢竟沒事先料到會大改)
而我日更所經營出來的點閱率也就這樣掰了5888Please respect copyright.PENANAEOAg4iEPKF
現在要找某部作品除非你知道書名或筆名5888Please respect copyright.PENANAg9ZzCVTSnp
不然就是完全淹沒在簽約作品的洪流中5888Please respect copyright.PENANAYNgK6mhTsi
5888Please respect copyright.PENANAq8mpqasIa8
有部分創作者反應5888Please respect copyright.PENANAbloKz0CmGR
明明已經投稿卻搜不到自己作品5888Please respect copyright.PENANAb2j7iMEi9i
但這也可能是個人操作問題5888Please respect copyright.PENANAJFawXQRmIl
證據不足我就不拿出來鞭了
8、直接將簽約作品釘在首頁長期霸榜
直接看圖,一目瞭然
5888Please respect copyright.PENANAOAGF3UvZxI
【最新連載】前三格永遠跟【簽約作品】前三格一樣5888Please respect copyright.PENANA5ivHYQn0T0
觀看數都累積到18萬5888Please respect copyright.PENANAaLsbUCU1pL
好意思說是「最新連載」?5888Please respect copyright.PENANAoXkS0Ax9SP
說網頁BUG我還比較信咧5888Please respect copyright.PENANAMp9OaJdeRs
然後這「BUG」都一年多了還沒有要修的意思5888Please respect copyright.PENANAVWxU9I60y2(所以不是BUG是刻意為之囉?)
使用者一進你們首頁往下滑5888Please respect copyright.PENANAGQt5FsmNPi
率先映入眼簾的東西就是這個5888Please respect copyright.PENANAQceMi5VlGg
對素人創作者來說極為珍貴的【最新連載】8格5888Please respect copyright.PENANAqbHXl860EP
前3格就這樣被浪費掉了
啊抱歉!不該說浪費!5888Please respect copyright.PENANAP4qb0oL2aF
應該說妥善使用才對5888Please respect copyright.PENANAXms2X26i8K
畢竟維護網頁也要成本啊!5888Please respect copyright.PENANATBQKFakOf1
用來宣傳自家簽約作品是理所當然的嘛!5888Please respect copyright.PENANArdka5oM5Tm(其他素人作家7414啦!)
這個點閱率沒有希望,真是謝囉!角角!
另一位匿名作家提供的資料5888Please respect copyright.PENANADJtBYLBds4
點閱率一樣從6月初開始銳減
5888Please respect copyright.PENANAwTJ1bnw4Zm
9、形同虛設的提款制度
剛開始看到【累積收益】四個字我眼眶都濕了
5888Please respect copyright.PENANA6yIW4wseVr
直到日積月累下來看到成果後……
左邊是我,右邊是另一位作家
點閱率差4倍5888Please respect copyright.PENANA6NUqm29j3j
累積收益也剛好差4倍5888Please respect copyright.PENANA1trEm1Qnq9
照這比例算下去5888Please respect copyright.PENANALdEnVrgMae
現階段要達到提領門檻的1000元5888Please respect copyright.PENANAHUmPQeltUf
大約得要有20萬點閱
5888Please respect copyright.PENANATwh1tK7S0u
5888Please respect copyright.PENANAT4UfeVbDWB
20萬點閱什麼概念?5888Please respect copyright.PENANApK4GEjDXwj
這本BL神作在首頁推送了數個月5888Please respect copyright.PENANA1pwzHOQjUJ
角角粉絲團還親自PO文宣傳5888Please respect copyright.PENANAuo1E6TjJ71
點閱率是18萬5888Please respect copyright.PENANAKMlRDGjblQ
目前(7/9)是我在角角看到最高的點閱5888Please respect copyright.PENANAzO6xfKV4Zx
(怎麼那麼好,付多少錢買廣告才有這待遇?)5888Please respect copyright.PENANAIdQKJ9B0dM
(1000元不知道買不買得到?)5888Please respect copyright.PENANAGENJs3FIX2
5888Please respect copyright.PENANArD42czw6Cx
連有如此優渥待遇的簽約作家都領不到這1000元5888Please respect copyright.PENANAhOyNEcGTxS
請問我們這些連首頁都上不了的素人5888Please respect copyright.PENANApPqf7hyAkj
是不是只能去旁邊玩小X雞啊?
5888Please respect copyright.PENANAx5pYXG13lo
哪位創作者有透過廣告收益領到1000元的5888Please respect copyright.PENANAmQoi6ijf7k
麻煩一定要來聯繫我5888Please respect copyright.PENANABhA3DjC49H
我真的想知道這部分實際是怎麼運作5888Please respect copyright.PENANAslHHI89yDO
如果廣告收益確實可行5888Please respect copyright.PENANAIPHC4NkuTP
那我願意收回這裡的話5888Please respect copyright.PENANAlAUhYjdRDh
5888Please respect copyright.PENANAi0qKUWUK73
10、秀弘人氣獎事件#1
真正讓我想寫這篇文的主因5888Please respect copyright.PENANA8xqbdGNK3i
是這令人極度不適的操作
事件起因在於角角公布了人氣獎二期得主5888Please respect copyright.PENANAuRR9hrE1m9
和第一期是同一位作者──秀弘
角角者官方文章連結5888Please respect copyright.PENANAzWpdpNpLgE
5888Please respect copyright.PENANAFF1Bx1WkYe
得了人氣獎應該是值得高興的事5888Please respect copyright.PENANA123H864meX
但得獎者本人卻不這麼認為5888Please respect copyright.PENANA30OpswO26x
因為比賽官方私下發了一封信給得主5888Please respect copyright.PENANA7FVJK8McaM
質疑他以「利益交換」形式鼓勵網友投票5888Please respect copyright.PENANAmJFzkjyoX1
這讓秀弘一整個直接爆氣5888Please respect copyright.PENANASt67lxamhm
秀弘粉絲團連結5888Please respect copyright.PENANAbFHP4pIk0S
5888Please respect copyright.PENANAPDgd5aNJPz
看到這我就有個問題了5888Please respect copyright.PENANAjYkG0fcJDN
正常我們思考的「利益交換」5888Please respect copyright.PENANAB931g40QTS
不就是所謂的「買票」嗎?5888Please respect copyright.PENANAqrluKfTY4j
【我給你錢(or其他有價物),你投票給我】5888Please respect copyright.PENANA4VPdYburpL
跟5888Please respect copyright.PENANApAG9ziwL4K
【得獎後承諾讀者將會做出回饋】5888Please respect copyright.PENANAJvLyp6qB1E
完全是不同的動機欸?5888Please respect copyright.PENANABr5SbQAaEZ
5888Please respect copyright.PENANAFBKpxE5CI8
在《百萬小說創作大賞》的規則下5888Please respect copyright.PENANAYxs3ymhy7u
候選人帶著政見參選竟然視同賄選耶!5888Please respect copyright.PENANA0E6dt0SQS2
真是前衛!
雖然我打一開始就不相信這比賽的公信力5888Please respect copyright.PENANA7pqqlbsOvP
但能不能麻煩小編對自己訂的規則多點信心啊?5888Please respect copyright.PENANAA4nVS35gYC
質疑得獎者的正當性5888Please respect copyright.PENANAveXvd4OKPs
等於你潛意識認為這場比賽就是個笑話5888Please respect copyright.PENANAkl1djMzl5b
5888Please respect copyright.PENANArPFRhQ3otr
所以人家得獎5888Please respect copyright.PENANAVzYhNkq2RW
官方做的第一件事不是恭喜5888Please respect copyright.PENANA4JEzif33Up
而是跑去跟他說:5888Please respect copyright.PENANAyAnQz2sxCP
「嘿!你被檢舉了!我們會考慮拔掉你的獎項!」
角角這個邏輯等於是5888Please respect copyright.PENANAdsO4pra3dU
【他們自己都不相信自己訂的規則能選出好作品】5888Please respect copyright.PENANAaeUngtyDLc
5888Please respect copyright.PENANAxTi6cdLOyd
11、秀弘人氣獎事件#2
繼上述事件後5888Please respect copyright.PENANArl1GU4HXhP
角角直接不演了5888Please respect copyright.PENANAnFbRPeR3pl
比賽規則臨時說改就改5888Please respect copyright.PENANAgwYdsbwqxB
現在一位作者最多只能得兩次人氣獎
這是用網頁時光機查到6/6的存檔5888Please respect copyright.PENANAz4kDXS9WFO
(感謝 戴斯蒙 大大教我用,5888Please respect copyright.PENANA8HKdTJnQuo
不然就跟上面第7點一樣死無對證了)
規則在不知不覺中直接追加一條
奇怪,這種事不是一開始訂規則就該想到嗎?5888Please respect copyright.PENANAlPYqyUXGKf
比賽都辦下去後5888Please respect copyright.PENANAOACBWXf1WB
一有人檢舉馬上改規則+警告得獎者5888Please respect copyright.PENANA5iRrqxPHuE
到底什麼迷之操作?5888Please respect copyright.PENANAOA0xBkNC2o
既不尊重自己的比賽也不尊重得獎者5888Please respect copyright.PENANAg7JKR40TJi
好歹發信警告前也先查證一下吧?5888Please respect copyright.PENANAG8kTxSh5ch
官方聲稱得獎者被檢舉而立即更改比賽規則5888Please respect copyright.PENANAt4bCLuHbvT
選手名聲難道不會被你們搞臭嗎?5888Please respect copyright.PENANA4aCGVNmQar
他的粉絲跟其他同行會怎麼看待他?
所以辦比賽前規則要想好5888Please respect copyright.PENANAolCLiq9vzr
官方要善用規則來鞏固公信力啊!5888Please respect copyright.PENANAzpByYqoZfr
隨便質疑得獎者搞得氣氛緊張、互相猜忌5888Please respect copyright.PENANAY0yd7voo4k
連官方自己的臉也丟大了!5888Please respect copyright.PENANA27oE43cDQ6
5888Please respect copyright.PENANAK0aC1jz2mK
12、第八期人氣獎誤植事件
感覺角角似乎在背後下著一盤大棋呀5888Please respect copyright.PENANASBQ9U7qqJI
繼秀弘的爭議事件後5888Please respect copyright.PENANAj53NnliZI8
第三、四期的人氣獎被人指出票數異常5888Please respect copyright.PENANAPAWIllXhqC
且書名和中國某些作品雷同,有抄襲嫌疑5888Please respect copyright.PENANAPljK9FDpb8
但沒造成太大風波我也懶得深究了5888Please respect copyright.PENANAuC3T5lLqft
反正錢是角角的5888Please respect copyright.PENANAy6Ts7PA9cl
他們想發給誰是他們的自由5888Please respect copyright.PENANApavuySpu7Z
本來是這樣想……
直到第八期人氣獎5888Please respect copyright.PENANAoMT23M2IbL
才有人逮到了角角疑似【黑箱作業】的線索5888Please respect copyright.PENANA9oR4tvT9Sh
除了某幾部作品票數異常飆高之外5888Please respect copyright.PENANA2RtRDDbB2c
角角還以「有網軍灌票」為藉口5888Please respect copyright.PENANAQ2hPKRi9Ri
大量刪除許多作品的票數5888Please respect copyright.PENANAhcTVnpD1MD
就這樣一來一往5888Please respect copyright.PENANALaldgPGvTi
中間可操作的空間實在很大5888Please respect copyright.PENANACLj4d4Uu9g
5888Please respect copyright.PENANAWwqCGJ5Jr8
在這樣的傳言之下5888Please respect copyright.PENANA7cZQZ598ov
第八期的參賽者為了自保5888Please respect copyright.PENANA4qL2v4K9AZ
在結算前把自己的票數截圖存證5888Please respect copyright.PENANAQUEMNPks1X
5888Please respect copyright.PENANAHk1rtQ2W3j
最後角角公布的作品比真正得主還少了200多票5888Please respect copyright.PENANAs9u1hyj0FU
作者直接在官方FB貼出截圖5888Please respect copyright.PENANALVjkCTbeQx
逼得他們不得不出來道歉5888Please respect copyright.PENANAxYVqQ082JD
5888Please respect copyright.PENANAIXjiYyqODP
是不是真的黑箱窩不知道5888Please respect copyright.PENANAZE68KNN5ir
我只知道......真的很難看啊!角角!5888Please respect copyright.PENANAXWmKViWpd3
你們有那麼多辦比賽的經驗5888Please respect copyright.PENANA8V6xhimLfd
怎麼還能辦成這樣?優秀!
13、複選名單爭議事件,官方賽程定義不明
這就是讓我在10/31這天回來更新的理由5888Please respect copyright.PENANAxnL553CvXN
首先讓我們看看賽程
今天是10/315888Please respect copyright.PENANARBpLoTO5qD
也就是賽程中的複選名單公告5888Please respect copyright.PENANAOC3VemN8Ls
然而這份名單當中,只有49部作品
什麼意思?5888Please respect copyright.PENANA3fdRVh4i37
投稿截止日是9/305888Please respect copyright.PENANApe8uRk9cps
今天是10/315888Please respect copyright.PENANAXId4JO64JS
5888Please respect copyright.PENANAZcB5GrnGq9
也就是說,角角的4位評審5888Please respect copyright.PENANA384B5cBDa3
在不到32天的時間裡5888Please respect copyright.PENANAO6M9UUvy1d
把1200多部作品全部看完5888Please respect copyright.PENANAkE9DM9xf7M
從中選出了49部5888Please respect copyright.PENANAJPRP3o0Heg
(感謝 十字菱 大大,身體力行幫大家數完了)
有些人可能會說5888Please respect copyright.PENANAjN5X0flalk
他們募集1200部作品,不一定會全看完5888Please respect copyright.PENANAEslssMNy7P
5888Please respect copyright.PENANAmzSMVHWjzH
基本上,我也同意這個論述5888Please respect copyright.PENANArM9OhdRURe
根據商業考量5888Please respect copyright.PENANACPaYSrYUkd
很多書出版社編輯只要看前三章就定生死了5888Please respect copyright.PENANAHyn0X1xd5a
這點大家都心知肚明,但是......5888Please respect copyright.PENANAcrM2ziky1H
5888Please respect copyright.PENANAN8fMSXUYXj
你們社群小編做死啊!5888Please respect copyright.PENANA1dSKDz6YhD
親口說會全部看完!!5888Please respect copyright.PENANA3xmfBGleYM
說好不會埋沒大家辛苦堆砌的作品!!!
4個評審32天要看完1200多部作品5888Please respect copyright.PENANALtW01EsMmP
平均下來每人一天至少要看37.5本書......5888Please respect copyright.PENANAa4Z2zTb1lr
這閱讀速度根本怪物等級了吧?5888Please respect copyright.PENANAqA31q7o7AD
一目百行是吧?5888Please respect copyright.PENANAQinv2iAdLj
5888Please respect copyright.PENANAR5NhuuVSRv
其次還有一個很弔詭的問題5888Please respect copyright.PENANAIviTNrKURl
為什麼是先公布複選名單才進入複選環節?5888Please respect copyright.PENANAHmdAj04YDd
5888Please respect copyright.PENANAVsjJu8qpBx
按評選方式來看5888Please respect copyright.PENANAccYMufqdua
初選應該只是主辦單位確認資格5888Please respect copyright.PENANA5A2Hl1aqiS
(看看字數、題材合不合基本規則)5888Please respect copyright.PENANALltusztwWw
5888Please respect copyright.PENANA7dsOIBZtzv
但現在看來不是這麼回事5888Please respect copyright.PENANAmlkzJiIO6F
初選才剛結束就已經篩到剩49部作品5888Please respect copyright.PENANAdE3a7JHA71
那請問那些被篩掉的作品5888Please respect copyright.PENANANOYjRNKqQl
究竟是資格不符被淘汰5888Please respect copyright.PENANA3nVc4sxGHk
還是被「主辦單位」片面淘汰?5888Please respect copyright.PENANAzASD8Sj3ih
四位評審究竟有沒有看過全部作品?5888Please respect copyright.PENANAMWj21HaoPk
5888Please respect copyright.PENANAoErr8lkaGq
再來,如果10/31公布的複選名單5888Please respect copyright.PENANA8RSphgo1lq
就是複選的結果5888Please respect copyright.PENANAMFlEgPoTsb
那請問賽程部分11月的複選又要怎麼進行...?5888Please respect copyright.PENANA2rpSq65G82
越想下去越覺得難以理解5888Please respect copyright.PENANAAhlwlcX3NH
總之,讓我們繼續看下去吧......
14、角角在 11/1 關閉社團功能,開始箝制言論自由
5888Please respect copyright.PENANAY7E41EUZgo
角角者!真有你的啊!5888Please respect copyright.PENANATTkGGyxVEO
嘴上說只會處置引戰或嘲諷的「留言」5888Please respect copyright.PENANADWvbJWvW5j
實際上卻是關閉整個留言功能5888Please respect copyright.PENANACPppypbMVs
甚至連社團發文功能都關閉了5888Please respect copyright.PENANA7yXdIl1u50
關閉社團討論區不給燒5888Please respect copyright.PENANAkRPljp2StF
想搞冷處理是吧QQ5888Please respect copyright.PENANAsYZS9XUPyy
要是再把逆風留言刪一刪5888Please respect copyright.PENANALfq0srbNLb
多招募一些網軍來洗留言5888Please respect copyright.PENANAQCnrePZAoT
那就更完美了呢!
【11/3 更新】
角角箝制言論的行為導致開始有人嘲諷他們一言堂5888Please respect copyright.PENANAp94ADoF9b9
最後不得已5888Please respect copyright.PENANAbHnBykNWUy
關閉不到48小時又開放社團貼文囉~5888Please respect copyright.PENANAs3rqpVGiLn
這個角角就是讚💗5888Please respect copyright.PENANA8zbmIXmEyn
該誇獎的地方還是要誇!5888Please respect copyright.PENANAbPlXMKjCdI啊所以你們昨天是為什麼關留言?5888Please respect copyright.PENANATuQE9fUrwN
以為關留言就燒不起來了嗎?真是可愛~
15、入選作品段落重複,是放水還是根本沒看內文?
在這邊先聲明一下5888Please respect copyright.PENANA2kB606ipgh
雖然有部分人已經開始懷疑名單「內定」5888Please respect copyright.PENANAKWEmUIt0Gk
但目前證據不足(或著也可以說舉證困難)5888Please respect copyright.PENANATfO1j1Iexv
因此我還是預設這些進入複選名單的人5888Please respect copyright.PENANA4I8RXg18Lg
都是不知情、無辜的參賽者
也請大家不要苛責被我點名的這部作品5888Please respect copyright.PENANAm5E46tLYXP
錯不在他5888Please respect copyright.PENANAKAi1qSTV9J
錯在不尊重這場比賽、5888Please respect copyright.PENANAVrYGhY7W8q
不尊重參賽者的角角者身上
聲明結束,以下看圖5888Please respect copyright.PENANAGmEN5rOm1F
5888Please respect copyright.PENANAJVxaVSekFx
方便大家傳閱,這邊提供圖片網址,歡迎下載取用、轉傳5888Please respect copyright.PENANAyWIutEM5vo
5888Please respect copyright.PENANAXEWYciGCFN
這是參加【短篇小說組】的作品5888Please respect copyright.PENANApnYb2fhuOA
總字數為1萬2千3百字5888Please respect copyright.PENANAhUS0Y62NRJ
這部作品的第一話5888Please respect copyright.PENANApfgOV2EwYB
可能是作者複製貼上時不小心按到5888Please respect copyright.PENANAvVyVUqOmhl
導致一大段重複了兩次5888Please respect copyright.PENANAFRJ03w3j9u
(幾乎一樣,只差了幾個字)5888Please respect copyright.PENANAIs21K5R7oE
5888Please respect copyright.PENANAOZVwhajEyR
所以我想問5888Please respect copyright.PENANAbsiMFNu0LU
角角者複選名單的篩選條件是什麼?5888Please respect copyright.PENANA6EvbikXOvR
主辦單位真的有看作品?5888Please respect copyright.PENANAg4JdoHHumA
更多更優秀的作品沒有被選上5888Please respect copyright.PENANAainZV9QPOu
反而這個在第一話就出現嚴重失誤的作品5888Please respect copyright.PENANAVoKFZYOffU
被選入名單之內......5888Please respect copyright.PENANAYTQTWeMjMQ
到底入選的標準是什麼?5888Please respect copyright.PENANAOGXKQ5D60v
該不會像第八期人氣獎那樣5888Please respect copyright.PENANAhusZyrMgGS
又是不小心誤植了吧?5888Please respect copyright.PENANAvh73havsJt
5888Please respect copyright.PENANAnG6D2wNHwt
如果這部作品入選,而其他作品沒有5888Please respect copyright.PENANAS0WAo5Ldc0
這對那些不停重複校稿、5888Please respect copyright.PENANAcADErlBRTU
一字一句都精挑細選、再三斟酌的創作者來說5888Please respect copyright.PENANA9S4ZPtoKQI
是多大的侮辱?
16、角角官方針對初選流程進行說明
本條目承接第13點5888Please respect copyright.PENANALqPG7yavIb
因為角角做了回應,所以我必須回應5888Please respect copyright.PENANAhkQzFgYaYP
不然有人會拿角角那篇來懟我5888Please respect copyright.PENANA0H9PFsryZd
(嘿對,在留言區就有一位了)5888Please respect copyright.PENANAHyGEbzvZfv
總之先上圖5888Please respect copyright.PENANAf1ajbPQWKL
5888Please respect copyright.PENANACapOGZTbRP
5888Please respect copyright.PENANAPpjQhYN0CK
在我嘴完角角請來的評審5888Please respect copyright.PENANAU4DgtdfC01
都是一天看37.5本書的怪物後5888Please respect copyright.PENANAD9awTQvIen
官方終於被我逼到不得不發表聲明了啊5888Please respect copyright.PENANAnDTqy5N1eo
(好啦沒有,這我自己感覺良好而已)5888Please respect copyright.PENANAwUiB485BSu
5888Please respect copyright.PENANAP87Ybl5o8K
總之,初選的部分多了一條隱藏規則叫做5888Please respect copyright.PENANAcKMVbGmvkB
【內部遴選】5888Please respect copyright.PENANAYGoyPT2Qkg
那我就又要貼這張圖出來了
怪哉!5888Please respect copyright.PENANAgcha9Nbwc5
5888Please respect copyright.PENANAW7qlxCo0VE
當初明明說初選是【針對申請資格進行審查】啊5888Please respect copyright.PENANAkAneCQuYrH
所以……規則難道又又又改了!?5888Please respect copyright.PENANAHUXogF6p8h
(奇怪我怎麼說了那麼多次又呢?)5888Please respect copyright.PENANAI6kWsTQvRw
5888Please respect copyright.PENANAM8joPGenzX
更令人傻眼的是5888Please respect copyright.PENANA9tbdG5SIFy
原來一位評審只負責一個類別……5888Please respect copyright.PENANArvkwqnwur3
有一位評審要看幾十萬字5888Please respect copyright.PENANAPoOLesffTy
其他評審只要看幾萬……5888Please respect copyright.PENANAZOSHH7oRgW
5888Please respect copyright.PENANA5HQREnTP4j看幾十萬字那位會不會幹在心裡啊5888Please respect copyright.PENANARIKPzADsux
同樣都是評審為什麼我要看這麼多字😂
5888Please respect copyright.PENANAWGKv5V58Gk
角角你們繼續亂搞5888Please respect copyright.PENANAclr1KT1A3G
我這篇文就繼續更新下去🥰5888Please respect copyright.PENANA7swTN18405
5888Please respect copyright.PENANAB825BS1CaY
【結論】
會炮那麼多主要是貓橘事件讓我對角川信心全無5888Please respect copyright.PENANAGm2YMqslVj
好不容易以為他們這次要洗刷汙名5888Please respect copyright.PENANAyx3ZHJ5Utz
給創作者打一劑強心針5888Please respect copyright.PENANACWt5FdBsbq
沒想到還是搞得烏煙瘴氣
7/7 預測5888Please respect copyright.PENANAfxkd9xuW3B
總之我先猜5888Please respect copyright.PENANAHdfyBpChog
這次第一名會是至少出過一本書的作家5888Please respect copyright.PENANAPOhuUSMF7F
理由等真的猜中了再來公布5888Please respect copyright.PENANAmAunR3TWbP
猜錯大家聽聽笑笑就好
角角者本次比賽要找的是即戰力5888Please respect copyright.PENANAymkvvZpV99
所以會從出過書的作家中進行挑選5888Please respect copyright.PENANAMGROIfwCGo
當然,這是我個人的猜測5888Please respect copyright.PENANApR8f1ohVCl
也可能出乎我預料就是了5888Please respect copyright.PENANAxzo5X8wXSI
5888Please respect copyright.PENANAQGXao7x0OP
各位覺得角角者知道自己網站的問題嗎?5888Please respect copyright.PENANAd6dtMp5D3c
不如分享出去,讓角川看看?