Summary: Set in S5E5 "Monster's Ball." What if Elena had stopped Damon from feeding Katherine to Silas, not wanting Katherine to die or be killed by Damon?494Please respect copyright.PENANAnundMtsZO2
It was a dark night in Mystic Falls, Virginia as Elena stood in shock. Damon was feeding Katherine to Silas. It didn't last for long, though. At vamp speed, Elena through Damon away from her. Then she got Katherine away from Silas and stood between Katherine and Damon.494Please respect copyright.PENANArWLy54KufD
"Enough," she said.494Please respect copyright.PENANAmEys4tihXG
"It's the only way to bring Bonnie back. You need her, Elena."494Please respect copyright.PENANAiU5kEWaaTk
"Katherine doesn't need to die just so we can get Bonnie back. We all miss her, but she's not gone. She's always around. What we need is to find a way to kill Silas without killing Katherine."494Please respect copyright.PENANAfBKvSfdL9N
"There is no other way," he insisted.494Please respect copyright.PENANAKY5bviHIZ3
"You just want her to die. I think she deserves a chance to live. So please, Damon. Don't let her die. She deserves a second chance."494Please respect copyright.PENANAXKhHbSh3fV
As Elena tried to convince Damon, protecting Katherine, Katherine watched with blurry vision, back up against a wall, before everything went black for her.494Please respect copyright.PENANAlHrhI26UcZ
Realizing Elena wouldn't let anything happen to Katherine, Damon left the house to go for a walk, as to not hurt Elena.494Please respect copyright.PENANAMe2oudqDdP
Once he had left, Elena was instantly at her side.494Please respect copyright.PENANA3AXqrJNuxf
She knelt by her and gently pulled her into her arms, before biting her wrist and putting it to her lips, making her blood go down her throat to heal her.494Please respect copyright.PENANAXS7kiaQDEM
A few minutes later, she took her wrist away and it instantly healed. Then, using vamp strength, she gently picked her up in her arms and headed for the stairs to lay her down on one of the beds.494Please respect copyright.PENANAjgKN86mPTx
In the end, everyone was okay with Katherine living and Silas unable to hurt anyone, considering what his ex-fiancée did to him.494Please respect copyright.PENANAjJqzeyBXty