In the dim light of the screening room, the flicker of the screen cast a pale glow across Dick’s face.109Please respect copyright.PENANA48rUdXUvRt
He sat in the very last row, his shadow sliced into fragments by the rows of empty seats in front of him.
This was his third time watching the film.109Please respect copyright.PENANALbBiS7HVvk
Labeled as a “documentary.”109Please respect copyright.PENANAvk193cslFg
No reviews. No director.109Please respect copyright.PENANA7W0zASWBHC
Just: “Anonymous submission. Untraceable source.”
As if Claire had never existed.109Please respect copyright.PENANALwitKiRsFc
Not even enough myth for a “legend” tag.
109Please respect copyright.PENANAFPFolX55wW
After she sent them home, the world snapped back into its original timeline.109Please respect copyright.PENANAjpQ9ZiHZhm
Life resumed.109Please respect copyright.PENANA01oMUMseit
The city stayed loud.109Please respect copyright.PENANAZSto6vY6sA
The streets stayed crowded.109Please respect copyright.PENANAwCBGZMZ2oB
No one wondered where the woman from the little coffee shop had gone—109Please respect copyright.PENANATpAHUYzqlR
No one even remembered the place had ever existed.
That café?109Please respect copyright.PENANAcIBHvCtu6m
Gone without a trace.
The owner?109Please respect copyright.PENANA405QqBxYR7
Maybe just a trick of the light.
But Dick knew.109Please respect copyright.PENANA1OYNl8Pq7i
She had never really stayed.
She didn’t leave a goodbye.109Please respect copyright.PENANAlCQPlDJSZ8
Because she already knew goodbyes were meaningless to someone the world was bound to forget.
She had spent so long preparing, just for that one moment—109Please respect copyright.PENANAUZ3kmTiZRf
The second she sent them all back.
Dick’s eyes never left the screen.109Please respect copyright.PENANA7n4tICJBcg
That was the only place he could still see her.
Claire had smiled only once in the entire film.109Please respect copyright.PENANAfcLljNmprr
When he and Robin flew her across the skyline—109Please respect copyright.PENANAqlN8774vmJ
Under the city lights, she laughed like a kid, utterly joyful.109Please respect copyright.PENANAM2m6kooHUY
Just that once.
She had worked so hard. Fought so long. Been so alone.109Please respect copyright.PENANATs5hQ15AZQ
But never lost hope.
Her tone was always tinged with a quiet kind of madness—109Please respect copyright.PENANARjhwyDGIi2
Sharp, self-aware, painfully logical.
She knew exactly what she was doing.109Please respect copyright.PENANAei89tP9sn2
And she knew no one would remember.
Dick leaned back in his seat and let out a small, quiet laugh.109Please respect copyright.PENANAYrbwKUsnbm
“No wonder I kept visiting her every day back then.”
It wasn’t duty.109Please respect copyright.PENANA9H7ZWF8rOr
It wasn’t responsibility.109Please respect copyright.PENANAT4SbHy9oYz
It was gravity.109Please respect copyright.PENANAjawyvO8CLi
A pull.109Please respect copyright.PENANATm969TsNGu
Something unnamed and familiar.109Please respect copyright.PENANAEtWrvVapMK
Even though, at the time, he didn’t remember her at all.
The film was nearing its end.
Claire lay in the rubble, blood trailing from her left eye, whispering to him:109Please respect copyright.PENANALy1SjamDdC
“I won’t let you die, Dick.”
No one cried on-screen.109Please respect copyright.PENANAbtiFslDfYR
No one cried in real life either.
That was their goodbye.109Please respect copyright.PENANAaxINGp2CDn
No tears.109Please respect copyright.PENANAM9fdkoRIdO
No confessions.109Please respect copyright.PENANAhuPsLAg701
No promises.
Just a woman who kept her word—109Please respect copyright.PENANAQOQzsTHib6
Saved him.109Please respect copyright.PENANAFFe28XIn40
Saved them all.
And then watched her treasures walk away,109Please respect copyright.PENANAtlXY1REXBC
while she was left behind—brutally forgotten.
The theater lights dimmed.
Dick didn’t move.109Please respect copyright.PENANA3eKSL3jFyz
His hand clutched the armrest, his eyes still locked on the dead screen.
109Please respect copyright.PENANApkHQn0y5Wu
After they had watched the movie and finished discussing it in the Batcave,109Please respect copyright.PENANA8kVPjAAEkL
Dick spent that night trying hard to remember.109Please respect copyright.PENANANbfJcjj795
He repeated Claire’s name in his mind hundreds of times,109Please respect copyright.PENANAhq63eh8g0b
hoping that something—anything—would resurface.109Please respect copyright.PENANABCrERESpIa
A memory. A sound. A fragment would’ve been enough.
But nothing came. Absolutely nothing.109Please respect copyright.PENANAelfAUmAyPT
No laughter, no words, not even a flicker of those moments they once stood side by side.109Please respect copyright.PENANAKGLhfHHZE2
It was nothing like in the happyending movies—where memories return, and everyone reunites in joy.
Those times he spent with Claire—109Please respect copyright.PENANAcWaZ7OB3P9
those conversations they had—109Please respect copyright.PENANAwcEWwDi7lf
felt like they had been erased by some hidden “clean-up” button pressed every day.109Please respect copyright.PENANALFaBp9EjuW
Not a trace remained.
Some parts of it were captured in the film.109Please respect copyright.PENANAXfMFN6nvTp
But what about everything that wasn’t?109Please respect copyright.PENANAwYsaaqXhT7
Did those only exist in Claire’s memories, carried with her into a long, silent time?
What hurt Dick the most was the fact that Claire had chosen this.109Please respect copyright.PENANAlOmxYV7nEg
She chose to stay.109Please respect copyright.PENANAfsbVJUDedi
She didn’t leave herself a way out.
She had planned it all by herself, and carried it out alone.109Please respect copyright.PENANAJDWxK4qqNm
She had severed her timeline, becoming a spiral caught in time.109Please respect copyright.PENANAByzNYMRez2
She chose to wait.109Please respect copyright.PENANAsL4Ci2aC11
She chose to hide the treasure.109Please respect copyright.PENANAG2lMXhmtIg
Claire gave up everything — so the others could live.
After that, they were like two straight lines that once crossed,109Please respect copyright.PENANAdFcHQyBdUa
then each went their separate ways into the future.109Please respect copyright.PENANAGSsVt2SkYX
No— it was his future.
Claire had already let go of her timeline.109Please respect copyright.PENANA89dtqdq6ez
She stopped at the convergence point.109Please respect copyright.PENANAzUkXr63DLS
Dick was the one allowed to keep moving forward.
Dick tried not to imagine it—109Please respect copyright.PENANADd4JJkqolV
not to imagine how many times Claire had lived that same day alone.109Please respect copyright.PENANAxcO9bgCaSV
So many times, she forgot her mission.109Please respect copyright.PENANAEAECsZLey6
So long, she forgot the crack in the sky.109Please respect copyright.PENANAtVmaxpMSZp
So distant, she turned instead to Batman for help.
Dick felt a heavy weight press down on his chest—like an iron block, unmoving, breathless.
He realized then—he wanted to see her.109Please respect copyright.PENANAmNuJhf31PB
Not out of guilt.109Please respect copyright.PENANAMOTJqNpqeL
Not even to say thank you.
But out of that hollow, ripping ache that comes when something inside you screams: “I don’t want her to only exist in this film no one watches.”
He wanted to see her.109Please respect copyright.PENANA1jF43Oy9Fm
More than anything.
109Please respect copyright.PENANASQrrehgjej
109Please respect copyright.PENANALw4GDFRwaS
Just as Dick was still sitting there, thoughts circling, that hollow feeling in his chest hadn’t lifted—109Please respect copyright.PENANAJnD9BGHuQo
like he was drifting in some deep, uninhabited ocean—109Please respect copyright.PENANAoPP5dtQVfv
the screen suddenly lit up again.
He jolted, heart lurching.
The image flickered.109Please respect copyright.PENANAwuh3JKWRTE
A single line appeared:
“Behind the Silence”
…It was the behind-the-scenes footage.
He froze.
All of them—those costumed vigilantes—had been so eager to argue, to act, to do something,109Please respect copyright.PENANAO7mQZ4I4Vg
and not one of them had stayed behind to finish it.109Please respect copyright.PENANArEMWTDGj3G
Even him.109Please respect copyright.PENANAVHGMCdyW9T
Even he hadn’t known there was more.
The screen continued.
Claire stood on a rooftop, looking up at the arc the rocket had carved across the sky.109Please respect copyright.PENANAGHqKoY4I1z
The trail of fire faded slowly.109Please respect copyright.PENANAxH8zmR287X
Like she had personally released the world—109Please respect copyright.PENANAuiyht3cozG
and along with it, the only thing she called her treasure.
She stood there for a long, long time.
Then, she turned and went downstairs, stepping out into the street.
The city was empty.
Wind brushed past buildings.109Please respect copyright.PENANAg47moPyfqP
No cars.109Please respect copyright.PENANAbr0W0EylBv
No voices.109Please respect copyright.PENANA4acPJffwiX
Not even the purple-glue monsters dared come near.
It was silent—like a ruin the world had already forgotten.
Claire walked without a word.
The sound of her shoes echoed loudly against the pavement,109Please respect copyright.PENANA9ULmpZ6Lnd
painfully sharp in all that stillness.
She moved through the city she once knew like the back of her hand—109Please respect copyright.PENANAy83LYVO82e
where she brewed coffee, baked bagels, and cursed at life.
Her steps were slow, tired.
Like a traveler returning home after being lost too long.
She returned to that little coffee shop.109Please respect copyright.PENANAIaMW4uuwPK
The door was still there.
She climbed the stairs.109Please respect copyright.PENANAXRYVCbiQti
Each one felt like a descent into memory.
Finally, she reached her room.
The same bed.109Please respect copyright.PENANAE79Jov80TR
The same blanket she always kicked off in her sleep.
She lay down.109Please respect copyright.PENANA7Wy00sstPx
Didn’t say much.
Just gently pulled the covers over herself.
Closed her eyes.
And in her heart, just one quiet thought:
“Goodnight, Blüdhaven.”
109Please respect copyright.PENANAaGoIKvdtUT
The screen went dark.
This time, really dark.
The theater was filled only with cold light and silence.
That was Claire’s ending.109Please respect copyright.PENANAiHYXITv9V8
No recognition.109Please respect copyright.PENANA9XyUt9NGYA
No hugs.109Please respect copyright.PENANA0IexLYYwYg
No medals.
Just an empty room, a blanket pulled tight,109Please respect copyright.PENANAqT7vuuWiX9
and a whispered goodnight to a city that no longer remembered her.
Dick’s tears fell in silence.
109Please respect copyright.PENANAiDuaJs7UQf
109Please respect copyright.PENANAklggQ5RyWC
Leila sat on the couch, her palm gently resting on the curve of her belly, feeling the faint stir of the baby inside.109Please respect copyright.PENANApQWLGGD3DS
She listened quietly as Jason explained the aftermath of the meeting, his voice slow and deliberate.109Please respect copyright.PENANAaqLaQZdUu4
She paid close attention—not just to his words, but to the heaviness in his tone.
She hadn’t finished the film last time.109Please respect copyright.PENANA4Np8RmcKw1
She’d been too exhausted.109Please respect copyright.PENANASPJdJerj9f
The baby wouldn’t stop kicking that day, rolling and turning nonstop, leaving her too tired to sleep the entire afternoon.
“It really doesn’t sound hopeful, does it?” she thought, reading the unspoken weight in Jason’s eyes.
She remembered Batman returning with a look darker than anything she’d seen—even during global crises.109Please respect copyright.PENANAWqcqIFeYBp
What he brought back cast a heavy silence over the Batcave.109Please respect copyright.PENANAbFPs4ddf83
No one joked.109Please respect copyright.PENANAt7YAH4Wven
Even Tim, usually talkative, simply stared at the files in silence.
Leila reached out and took Jason’s hand gently.109Please respect copyright.PENANAGq87wAnfQp
She knew he was holding himself together for everyone else.109Please respect copyright.PENANAUr7Ovv8k38
But the quiet way she laced her fingers through his was her way of reminding him—softly, silently—that he didn’t have to carry it alone.
Jason paused, startled by the touch, and whispered, “Sorry, Leila, I just...”
She shook her head and started signing.
“I want to ask something.”
Jason watched her hands carefully and nodded. “What is it?”
Her fingers moved again, calm and deliberate.
“Can we ask Bat-Mite for help? Remember—he was the one who gave me that film as a fan gift.”
Jason blinked, clearly thrown off by the suggestion.
“I… hadn’t thought of that,” he admitted. “But the Bat—he’s always been wary of fifth-dimensional beings. Thinks they’re too unpredictable, too dangerous to deal with.”
Leila signed with steady insistence:
“But that’s exactly why we need Bat-Mite. We need help from someone outside the rules. At the very least… we can ask him where Claire is right now. Then we’ll know how to move forward.”
Her hands didn’t falter, her rhythm sure and warm:
“Let me try, Jason. Bat-Mite’s my fan, remember? Don’t forget that.”
She smiled gently, her gaze firm but kind.
Jason stared at her for a long moment, then finally nodded.
“…Alright. We’ll try.”
Leila smiled, the corners of her eyes softening, as if—just for a moment—109Please respect copyright.PENANAx9hzzEftzN
Claire’s hope had quietly stirred back to life.
109Please respect copyright.PENANACtE9Fgfpll


