1 : 北角琴行街一宗奪命車禍,一輛私家車轉彎後誤入行車道,逆線行駛直撞向過路人群,剷向依法綠公仔過馬路的母女,慈母奮力推開兩歲女兒,結果女兒保住性命僅受輕傷,慈母卻不幸死亡......肇事私家車女司機李×清(44歲),居於港島半山司徒拔道豪宅區。其座駕為本田「極品」,車上貼有馬場及深水灣遊艇會的泊車證,車頭亦掛有馬會的會員徽號。事發後有一名中年男子,駕駛一輛保時捷跑車到場,從旁協助李接受警員的調查。肇禍女司機原本被裁定危險駕駛引致他人死亡,判囚3個月,女司機昨日上訴得直,改判不小心駕駛罪成,輕判罰款5千元及停牌1年。244Please respect copyright.PENANA9RTTlx7gvO
(按:原審受3隻,已經係輕到離譜,佢都仲要上訴,可見毫無悔意。此案與第6,對比非常強烈)244Please respect copyright.PENANAC7tT8LdhG1
案件編號:HCMA 797/05 , ESCC 894/05244Please respect copyright.PENANAfOKhrb8aZq
244Please respect copyright.PENANAtPwxuVI8lL
244Please respect copyright.PENANAjH5AIgWgEO
2 : 隸屬新界南衝鋒隊高級警員杭富榮,去年七月請纓頂替腹瀉不適的車長駕駛警車趕赴處理一宗企圖自殺案,期間因超速及衝紅燈在葵福路十字路口狂撼的士造成一死三傷意外。輕判他罰款8千元及停牌半年。244Please respect copyright.PENANAnQRjY0z2ho
案件編號:TWCC102/06244Please respect copyright.PENANAnONbX0JEKo
244Please respect copyright.PENANAtc8olZC5y5
244Please respect copyright.PENANATx7XA8WKbG
3 : 解放軍軍營管理公司經理,去年在營內倒車時撞死清潔女工,被判不小心駕駛罪成,判罰180小時社會服務。244Please respect copyright.PENANALQvK49bPh1
案件編號:ESCC 248/06244Please respect copyright.PENANAtJCgGmOjP2
244Please respect copyright.PENANAF9PIqORRKC
4 : 生果商人.....駕駛借來的林寶堅尼跑車以高速衝向一輛的士,導致的士乘客被拋出車外死亡....被告.....有十四次交通定罪記錄,包括超速駕駛及不小心駕駛,曾被判罰款及停牌,未被判以監禁式刑罰.....裁判官昨狠批商人為不負責任及自私的駕駛者,判處入獄四個月及停牌年半,但准他保釋等候上訴。244Please respect copyright.PENANAfSaZJg7w94
案件編號:KCCC 438/05244Please respect copyright.PENANALaXDqntg9r
244Please respect copyright.PENANAfRWPP9DDyT
5:一名於跨國律師事務所出任合夥人的女律師.....撞斃1名婦人.....原本被控危險駕駛引致他人死亡罪......改控不小心駕駛罪.......罰3000港元,另須參與駕駛改進課程。244Please respect copyright.PENANAyHf1BjMyWB
案件編號:ESCC 529/2022244Please respect copyright.PENANAQPaVuvBbPY
244Please respect copyright.PENANAHNpTqZtPmf
244Please respect copyright.PENANAOliX3DoBjU
***********************************244Please respect copyright.PENANABkR6XB4JKd
244Please respect copyright.PENANA0GSAjuTMYh
6 : 泥頭車司機於九龍塘在沒有醉駕、超速及衝燈的情況下,不幸撞倒及輾斃因衝紅公仔過馬路的菲傭及僱主的6歲女兒.....事件起因是兩名死者違規衝紅燈過馬路....司機有悔意....判囚18個月,停牌5年。244Please respect copyright.PENANAfho2NItexL
案件編號:DCCC 159/2013244Please respect copyright.PENANAJXc9eu8TzM
244Please respect copyright.PENANAEYf1P9YnjE
7 : 小巴司機石明有去年在西貢越過雙白線爬頭,撞死正在比賽的單車手,危險駕駛罪成,判囚5個月,停牌兩年。244Please respect copyright.PENANAArmbczvQAg
案件編號:KTCC 2478/06244Please respect copyright.PENANAYUEABNxYOx
244Please respect copyright.PENANA0UVAPOsCf1
8 : 一名垃圾車司機在停牌期間駕車,倒車撞斃一名婦人,昨被判囚14個月停牌27年,事件成為不少報章頭條。244Please respect copyright.PENANAvJsoBk9TCa
案件編號:KCCC 5628/06244Please respect copyright.PENANAJzVBwsfsUT
244Please respect copyright.PENANAUazn01vJrU
9:一輛校巴於沙田大涌橋路失事.......車上學生及保姆等 25 人受輕傷(按:無人死亡)。57 歲校巴司機 ......囚 5 個月、停牌 18 個月。244Please respect copyright.PENANAfOySKhj8QW
案件編號:DCCC 139/2022244Please respect copyright.PENANAqKQf6wRFRC
244Please respect copyright.PENANAe8qoBmxPKa
10:有四十年駕駛經驗只曾有一次不小心駕駛紀錄、並曾獲選模範司機嘉許的六十七歲專線小巴男司機,去年因岳父患病,心不在然,在斑馬線撞死一名正橫過馬路的孝順女。他非常內疚,曾經想過自殺,之後為死者立靈位贖罪.....入獄兩年半,停牌五年,罰款二千元。244Please respect copyright.PENANAkHFVkzLzCj
案件編號:DCCC 159/2010244Please respect copyright.PENANAnUeDHp2IxZ
244Please respect copyright.PENANAy9BzdnHMoU
11:的士司機在迪士尼樂園的士站等客期間小睡,被樂園職員敲窗驚醒後匆忙開車,當見前方有人時欲煞車卻誤踏油門.....撞死兩名落車閒聊的男行家。涉案五十八歲被告劉賢平早前在區院承認一項危險駕駛導致他人死亡罪........判監兩年及停牌五年。244Please respect copyright.PENANAPgE4YTbzuY
案件編號:DCCC 825/2013244Please respect copyright.PENANAhRX0epFkz0
244Please respect copyright.PENANAjWhZ5ZUXzv
***********************************244Please respect copyright.PENANA6os9y6CrpP
244Please respect copyright.PENANAXy8MygQ88L
有師兄指出,1至5的確過輕,而6至11除咗6係唔合理,其他都唔算判得重。判坐監亦唔係因為窮人,而係因為「職業司機」身份。職業司機要長時間駕駛,比一般人更要求良好駕駛態度,所以要有更重阻嚇罰則。244Please respect copyright.PENANA3DHcOfYqqt
職業司機是否真的判得較重?也未必,例如7也過輕。244Please respect copyright.PENANAMgZVnmYda6
244Please respect copyright.PENANAYtkqc0WDtV
244Please respect copyright.PENANA7KlaQnBPVk
***********************************244Please respect copyright.PENANAo5Aqx2H2EX
244Please respect copyright.PENANAqv6alo9AVg
比1至5相對正常,但仍然偏輕既例子244Please respect copyright.PENANA8Sf1W7skNf
244Please respect copyright.PENANAcw5pUcKa0u
12:地產經紀深夜駕駛黑色寶馬私家車途經沙田牛皮沙街時,聲稱一時分神切線至逆線,與迎頭駛來的一輛的士相撞......男的士司機死亡......女乘客嚴重受傷,經紀早前承認危險駕駛引致他人死亡,及危駕致他人身體受嚴重傷害等五罪.......被告駕駛前曾飲酒,雖然濃度並無超標,但肯定影響到其判斷力,......判監兩年,停牌5年,並需自費參與駕駛改進課程和罰款1500元。244Please respect copyright.PENANA1Rcbef8mMm
案件編號:DCCC 873/2019244Please respect copyright.PENANAAuC8529Xlj
arrow_back
萬年議題,隨心寫
more_vert
-
info_outline Info
-
toc Table of Contents
-
share Share
-
format_color_text Display Settings
-
exposure_plus_1 Recommend
-
Sponsor
-
report_problem Report
-
account_circle Login
Search stories, writers or societies
Continue ReadingClear All
What Others Are ReadingRefresh
X
Never miss what's happening on Penana!
萬年議題,隨心寫
Author:
拋棄夢裡人
ISSUE #3
[法律面前]12宗車禍,11宗有死人,判決對比(附案件編號)
LIKES 0
READS 240
BOOKMARKS 1
campaign
Request update 0
Sponsor
Suggest Edits
Login with Facebook
or Sign up/Login to comment or bookmark! Click to load the next chapter
X
After each update request, the author will receive a notification!
smartphone100
→ Request update
X
Sponsor again
Click to login
Login first to show your name as a sponsor.
Thank you for supporting the story! :)
Please Login first.
×
Write down what you like about the story
×
Reading Theme:
Font Size:
Line Spacing:
Paragraph Spacing:
Load the next issue automatically
Reset to default
×
People Who Like This
x
Before You Publish
Please ensure your story does not contain illegal, hateful, inciting, or violence-promoting content, or any infringing, plagiarized, or spam material, and that it complies with Penana’s Terms of Use.
Penana reserves the right to remove any content that violates these rules or causes legal or community risk, and to suspend or terminate related accounts.

