【原文出處】
https://www.penana.com/article/1606896
154Please respect copyright.PENANAZ13p3x0S8p
154Please respect copyright.PENANADA1dwTJo6k
以下是我看到某參賽作品以後,所寫的留言轉正文,供大家參考。
154Please respect copyright.PENANANWG8TAnaeJ
154Please respect copyright.PENANAwq5KrIcVIO
感謝參與~154Please respect copyright.PENANAVaXnU1dAfd
154Please respect copyright.PENANAZP8BjP8Bcu
老實說,這篇給我的感覺不是十行詩,是散文十行。154Please respect copyright.PENANA4QAV8yZ849
154Please respect copyright.PENANAkNeePZKQTP
雖然文章有哲理,但是詩度很低。詩的要素,如節奏、意象、音樂、譬喻都很平淡,甚至欠奉;內容太趨近說明,解釋過多,太黏了。154Please respect copyright.PENANA20l7m85vMi
154Please respect copyright.PENANAHJ1hqKzJZb
~~~~分隔線~~~~154Please respect copyright.PENANAi0PYDjmoyE
154Please respect copyright.PENANAspbt4NFzmM
我回頭看我自己寫的詩,有些也算不上是詩,例如154Please respect copyright.PENANAA8FzMowLWr
154Please respect copyright.PENANAbdsKYa56Vg
〈限制和自由〉154Please respect copyright.PENANARzT7hL1fZY
154Please respect copyright.PENANAieWRE8b9IS
penana.com/article/1024895154Please respect copyright.PENANAxd1OBrBFi4
154Please respect copyright.PENANAOOptrvjjUc
現在看來,我覺得它不是詩 (但為記錄故,還是收進詩集)。154Please respect copyright.PENANAJQXTMxreQN
154Please respect copyright.PENANAM9SFgyyhE3
詩度 0。154Please respect copyright.PENANAaP0CY5QIsB
154Please respect copyright.PENANAesQbTzhTyA
~~~~分隔線~~~~154Please respect copyright.PENANABnnONGRF11
154Please respect copyright.PENANAI6LLYQKnXW
〈問〉154Please respect copyright.PENANAn2rFqqWNpV
154Please respect copyright.PENANABqDEX5zhcp
penana.com/article/1024944154Please respect copyright.PENANAnwDH4D2vi8
154Please respect copyright.PENANAnDGR6FXYHc
詩度高一點。154Please respect copyright.PENANATqFweEE1eL
154Please respect copyright.PENANAnAHkXWvD9F
~~~~分隔線~~~~154Please respect copyright.PENANADRjDFesvh3
154Please respect copyright.PENANAaCuwDSj5YB
〈摩天之輪〉154Please respect copyright.PENANAQ0JGKtcKVk
154Please respect copyright.PENANAVYTGw5fNzm
penana.com/article/1045705154Please respect copyright.PENANA2plIXBOpnu
154Please respect copyright.PENANAWo7s8IaV8z
詩度再高一點。
154Please respect copyright.PENANAoNcOVs192A
~~~~分隔線~~~~
154Please respect copyright.PENANA7QcZnC37Ox
〈蝴蝶酥〉154Please respect copyright.PENANAyxpTEllmlF
154Please respect copyright.PENANAA1cGIZNNRJ
https://www.penana.com/article/1597713154Please respect copyright.PENANAoOJaJHDGbf
154Please respect copyright.PENANAi4QWEeQJwX
詩度比前三首都高。
154Please respect copyright.PENANAiOVhhSKHkP
~~~~分隔線~~~~
154Please respect copyright.PENANARG1GXxob8w
我最近在看台灣詩人蕭蕭的詩論,詩人有句話簡單卻有道理:「詩,是『換句話說』,『再換句話說』」。154Please respect copyright.PENANAtBUTKbErZQ
154Please respect copyright.PENANAmJSC1pe9TK
我在筆記本上面,寫下自己的句子:「詩,是常句和變句的雙人舞。」154Please respect copyright.PENANAaKZLJ9rlPa
154Please respect copyright.PENANA31XOwEwMAx
跟你分享。
154Please respect copyright.PENANAEwK4I3lJqI
~~~~分隔線~~~~
154Please respect copyright.PENANAB48LM1D44j
此外,這篇連結文章也可作參考。154Please respect copyright.PENANAbQ4DBP8ffn
154Please respect copyright.PENANA9E0MdKDJKs
【認識新詩的基本元素】154Please respect copyright.PENANA5WHqf5hVEy
154Please respect copyright.PENANAlFc55wYAzn
blog.udn.com/shesiya/113597193154Please respect copyright.PENANALnkMfkYKuA
154Please respect copyright.PENANAYjgDrvFsle
我之後應該會就我最近對新詩的思考&自己詩作/非詩作的例子,寫一篇文章放在我的《寫詩這件事及其他》裡面。154Please respect copyright.PENANAuQYKzpnTye
154Please respect copyright.PENANAiC9Ge1mHoc
154Please respect copyright.PENANAa9TcNpnZbW
154Please respect copyright.PENANAysbo5ES1N4
【我後來回答參賽者「希望較符合你的標準」的留言】
154Please respect copyright.PENANAoQdQkeqNy0
這不是我的標準啦,算是台灣詩人對新詩的定義。154Please respect copyright.PENANAAwlgs3mMZO
154Please respect copyright.PENANAklnKkVQL3N
第二版「詩度」有提升,因為用了複沓/排比結構,綿延的音樂性增加了。154Please respect copyright.PENANAtzXiIPoXpc
154Please respect copyright.PENANAK8JtMPGnct
寫詩要多看詩,也不用急,我檢視自己這兩年多密集寫詩的成果,發現好多不熟的,甚至是皮球假裝成果子的,哈哈~
154Please respect copyright.PENANAa23jad3raz
154Please respect copyright.PENANAFrQ1OP6hME
【這次全新寫的感想】
154Please respect copyright.PENANAZUUP1foBYc
我拿自己青澀的詩果,甚至非詩的皮球作例子,無非是希望讀者能做個比較,認識一下不同詩度的詩,長什麼樣子;這裡再拿我寫的〈詠栗〉為例:
154Please respect copyright.PENANAkbpEvH0W8P
〈詠栗〉
154Please respect copyright.PENANAuLcZYJQerm
殼斗,第一層愛
張牙舞爪威嚇
眾鳥獸,為了
豐美的內在
154Please respect copyright.PENANAoTjAQCxtzG
剝去愛,尚有
木訥果皮和刻苦種皮
無口而全然
環抱整個子代
154Please respect copyright.PENANAAwAjI9R9er
充盈在手中打開
當秋天到來
154Please respect copyright.PENANAYlsHLKmwOG
154Please respect copyright.PENANAH77LKgLcMv
如果寫成
154Please respect copyright.PENANA35rOkMighP
〈詠栗〉
154Please respect copyright.PENANA9rxPJ6wxtv
殼斗,第一層皮
長滿尖刺威嚇
眾鳥獸,為了
內在的果實
154Please respect copyright.PENANAhxN3RhGCke
剝去殼,尚有
木質果皮和苦味種皮
沒有裂口而且完全
包覆整個子葉
154Please respect copyright.PENANAvJ6FScseFd
栗子在手中打開
當秋天到來
154Please respect copyright.PENANAH6A2HKSmEf
詩度就不見啦,成為一篇分行的散文,而且是說明文。
154Please respect copyright.PENANAm5i6AI4Ad0
會寫詩的讀者,可將自己詩裡的詩句 (=變句),換成一般常用的句子 (=常句) 玩玩看;而苦惱於抓不到詩度的讀者,反其道而行,將自己作品的句子,改動幾個詞彙,以「一般不會這樣用」的語詞 (也可改變詞性) 代替,或可抓到一點詩的感覺。
154Please respect copyright.PENANAAYJy6dcM6N
當然,詩的面向不僅在於詞彙,但這是一個開始。
154Please respect copyright.PENANA0uKyDCIALH
祝各位被詩淋透,不,淋得半濕就好。
ns216.73.217.1da2