Dear C, (AKA, Cucumber. (Long story)),
313Please respect copyright.PENANA1UuHzjtlx0
313Please respect copyright.PENANAukkyERabhc
It's been five years. Five years since chubby-cheeked ten-year-old me, shy and reserved, met twelve-year-old you (an insanely older boy in my young, nieve eyes) in ballet class. Five years since I had my first real crush.
313Please respect copyright.PENANAtHK9bL5yBc
It was the small things at first, such as the class photo we took on my birthday when you and your younger brother each had to hold my hand. I still stare at that picture; the nervous smile on my face, the way my shoulders seemed to lift to my shoulders, the silver tiara atop my head, the grin on your lips...mainly the way you held my hand.
313Please respect copyright.PENANAvW311PL49S
I remember you'd say just a word to me, and my throat would go dry, look my way, and my heart would race. And then, in the spring, we were paired together in a dance; I had to hold your hand and dance around you. And while all of the other girls would cry about cooties and whine about dancing with a boy, I was truly excited to hold your hand every week during rehearsal.
313Please respect copyright.PENANAtrukSXy2aq
Then you left. I didn't see you for an entire year, and while perhaps I didn't know it but eleven-year-old me subconsciously still had a teeny tiny little crush on you, even if you weren't there anymore.
313Please respect copyright.PENANAlFF7N1bjkh
But, of course, when I least expected it, you showed up again, this time two years older than you were before. And I couldn't help but fall for you all over again. It was your eyes, and that smile, and maybe something about how you kinda looked like a heartbreaker at fourteen years old; something in my heart and head just kept leading me back to you.
313Please respect copyright.PENANAws3R2KSYtW
More often rather than not, I caught you watching me, or you'd look up, and our eyes would meet; you'd give me compliments, and I'd shyly accept them; adults began to point out the way you'd act around me, and pretend that I didn't know what they were talking about; my friends began to scheme, and you soon had a code name (cucumber). Even your sister teased me about you; I mean, tell me that doesn't mean something.
313Please respect copyright.PENANATJOZmPlWbQ
It was all going as planned until about two years ago. Dance classes went virtual, and of course, that kind of put a stunt in my plan.
313Please respect copyright.PENANAAW6CltTdP9
Just like that, it seemed I'd lost you again. You disappeared as you had a few years before.
313Please respect copyright.PENANAHoIegYAzil
I tried to convince myself that I was over you, that I had moved on because lets be honest, the odds seemed pretty against it. And after all, you were two years older; you were moving on with things like high school while I was hardly even a teenager.
313Please respect copyright.PENANAXhx4MtNBms
So then there was this thing that I convinced myself I had with this other boy, where I worked up the guts to tell him my supposed feelings for him only to end up hurt from the outcome. But, now, honestly, I know that it was all along an effort to get over you.
313Please respect copyright.PENANAFW9rGEq1lA
My friend ended up seeing you last summer, though you don't know that we know each other, and let me just say, the phone call I got from her later on, on how we were going to meet again was one full of hope and excitement. That was the day that my feelings for you came flooding on back.
313Please respect copyright.PENANAmh0tLQYyUr
I started to stalk your Instagram. Yeah, I know, I'm creepy, but I don't care, because honestly, you look like a model.
313Please respect copyright.PENANAjduoRJWqqe
My friends and I would have these wild discussions too, scheming on how we could possibly reunite us. I would scoff at their crazy ideas, but they would claim that they knew we would see each other again. At the time, I deemed them crazy, but now, I kinda have to give them credit. Because they, indeed, ended up being right.
313Please respect copyright.PENANAxjKCaMtvzy
I remember that November night rehearsal so clearly, sitting amongst a mass of other girls tying my pointe shoes when I heard your name. I'm not being dramatic when I say I literally started shaking when the teachers began to discuss the matter of you coming back for the Christmas ballet to serve in a role that our small cast hadn't managed to fill.
313Please respect copyright.PENANAMPvB0mQaiY
It was weeks later when I saw your face in person for the first time in almost two years. I knew that this was my last chance; I had to try to form a bond and create a state of communication between us so that I wouldn't lose you again.
313Please respect copyright.PENANA4BJw2BrPvR
So I set out on my mission. It began with small, tiny comments and brief eye contact, but eventually, it converted into discussions backstage, high fives, and wishing each other good luck before we'd go on stage.
313Please respect copyright.PENANAUGHrILqV8u
It was the last day of the show when I gave you a card with my number in it; whether you opened it and what you did with it after, I still have no clue.
313Please respect copyright.PENANABJW3ohMdNu
I waited for a text from you, a call, a sign you opened my card, but there was nothing. Soon, I found out that you had had a girlfriend, not that I had known, but she cheated on you. I remember wondering how someone could do that to a boy like you.
313Please respect copyright.PENANAdu8BX4AflI
I saw you a few more times after that, attended an open house at the Catholic school that your family owns, and then, a month later, shadowed as a potential future student. It didn't work out, but I walked out of it having heard you call me the best dancer ever. For me, that was enough.
313Please respect copyright.PENANAM83HVS3BtZ
Months later, at the beginning of the summer, you broke my heart without even knowing it. My mom came home from a meet-up with her friend bearing news that you were flirting with both of her friend's daughters over social media, and honestly, from the things you said to them, you didn't seem like the sweet religious boy that I thought you to be. Now, I know you didn't do anything directly to me at all but I felt betrayed because this brought me back to the neglected phone number and made me think that maybe you didn't like me all along. If I'm being honest, I cried in my bed that night over the person I thought you were. And I never cry.
313Please respect copyright.PENANAEsYmOABJiK
Now, I frankly don't know how I feel about you. I kind of want to show you that you can't have it all, even though you think you can. I want to show you that not all girls will just throw themselves down at your feet.
313Please respect copyright.PENANA8aR5q40Qwb
But a part of me, that part of me from five years ago, still loves you. Somehow, you've managed to steal my heart and break it all at once.
313Please respect copyright.PENANA9fqc54MCdZ
We'll see where this goes; we'll see,
313Please respect copyright.PENANAUBvjuw6t2Y
Sincerely,
313Please respect copyright.PENANA9Zl3JxCkUR
the quiet girl from dance
313Please respect copyright.PENANAbUJygoutxN
313Please respect copyright.PENANApFVjvnEIkq
313Please respect copyright.PENANANxzeP9GFd0
313Please respect copyright.PENANAXAtEoPaCY1
313Please respect copyright.PENANAHPfBtBABd9